Categories
30 Seconds to Proper Speech Proper Speech

Overhearing a Threat

An obvious case where conveying negative information is required is where a person is overheard plotting to harm someone. While we have seen that when a Jew may be in danger, even secondhand information can be related, it is imperative that one first determine that the plot is apparently serious and not a bad joke.

The condition that one first reprove the person against whom he intends to speak (see Day 45) applies only if one believes he can change the alleged plotter’s attitude. Otherwise, warning him would only induce him to modify the plot to ensure that it not be uncovered.

The remaining conditions are required here no less than in an ordinary case of constructive speech: One’s intent must be solely to avert harm (and not, for example, for the pleasure of thwarting the plotter); if an alternative exists – including not revealing the identity of the plotter – then that avenue must be pursued. Also, one must be reasonably sure that the plotter will not be caused undue harm. If the potential victim is known to be hot-tempered and can be expected to take revenge, he cannot be spoken to. Alternative means would have to be found to protect the victim without endangering the plotter. (The case of one who overhears a plotter will be discussed in greater detail in the laws of rechilus, gossipmongering.)

Categories
Family Lesson a Day

Problematic Praise II

SEFER CHOFETZ CHAIM — Hilchos Lashon Hara 9:3-4

“Mr. Friedman is such a wonderful person; the other day, he lent me $10,000.”

“If any of you ever needs a place to stay or a good meal, go to the Morgans. I stayed there for a week and they treated me like a king; every night I was served a five-course meal and they gave me exclusive use of their second car!”

It may come as a surprise that the Chofetz Chaim places the above statements in the category of avak lashon hara.

Yes, these statements are highly complimentary, but they could cause the person spoken about much distress. Mr. Friedman probably does not want the entire community to know that he lent this person $10,000. It is quite possible that there was a specific reason why he lent him such a large sum. Now that this was announced, people will come ringing his doorbell expecting the same — and he will have a hard time explaining to them that he cannot satisfy their requests. And, as the Chofetz Chaim notes, one or two dishonest people may be among those who will now request loans of him, and if he does honor their requests, he will later regret it.

The same applies to the guest who was treated so well by the Morgans. It is wrong for him to pub­licize their exceptional hospitality. This could bring unsavory people to their door who will be a source of aggravation to them.

However, if the man who received the loan knows that his friend, an honest person, needs to borrow money, he could tell him privately, “Speak to Mr. Friedman; he might be able to help you.”

And if the former guest knows that his friend needs to find lodging for a few days, he can pick up the phone and ask the Morgans if they would be able to host his friend.

The Chofetz Chaim concludes his discussion of avak lashon hara by cautioning us not to make statements that are in fact permissible, but which people might misinterpret as being lashon hara.

In the following chapter, we will learn of situations where lashon hara may be related l’to’eles (for a constructive purpose), but only in the presence of three or more. This is so that the speaker will avoid the impression that he is trying to be secretive because there is an element of falsehood in his report. If he does relate the information in a secretive way, thereby giving a bad impression, he is guilty of causing others to think that he is speaking lashon hara.

One should not socialize with baalei lashon hara, people who have little regard for the Torah’s prohibitions against speaking lashon hara, and who frequently engage in lashon hara.

If someone innocently sat down among a group and in the midst of conversation realized that the current topic is full-fledged lashon hara, he should speak up for the sake of Hashem and His Torah, and tell the others that such discussions are forbidden. Even if he knows that his words will be ignored, he should still speak up and make it clear that he is opposed to such discussions. The only time he should remain silent is when it seems that these people will react to criticism with anger and will speak even more lashon hara than they would have had he remained silent.

IN A NUTSHELL

Do not make complimentary statements about someone if this might cause him distress.

Voice disapproval when lashon hara is spoken, unless this will lead to more lashon hara.

 -A project of  Mesorah Publications –

Categories
Shmiras Haloshon

Change the Topic!

Categories
30 Seconds to Proper Speech Proper Speech

Possible Harm

Unlike other cases of constructive purpose, protecting someone from possible harm is permissible even when no firsthand information is available. If one happens to hear that one Jew is plotting to harm another, it is permissible to advise the potential victim to beware of the suspected plotter. In such a case, where the suspicions are based on hearsay, the information must not be presented as fact. It should be clearly stated that the concerns stem from unconfirmed secondhand information that may or may not be true.

The Chofetz Chaim maintains that although one who fails to warn his fellow Jew of impending danger is in violation of, “Do not stand aside while your fellow’s blood is being shed,” this does not apply when one is unable to personally verify that danger does, indeed, exist. Nevertheless, it is proper to convey even secondhand information if this might spare someone harm.

Categories
Family Lesson a Day

Problematic Praise I

SEFER CHOFETZ CHAIM — Hilchos Lashon Hara 9:1-2

Avak lashon hara (lit. the dust of lashon hara) refers to statements that are not actual lashon hara but do contain some aspect of lashon hara.

“Who would have believed that he would be where he is today?”

“Let’s not talk about him; I’d rather not speak about what happened.”

In both these statements, nothing bad has actually been said. However, they both hint to the possibility that there is something uncomplimentary about the person that is not being said:

“Who would have believed that he would be where he is today? Why, only five years ago, he was on the streets doing nothing with his life, and now he is a productive member of society.”

“Let’s not talk about him; I’d rather not speak about what happened. After all, we all like him. Why speak about something that is a stain on his reputation?”

We should never say something about a person that either hints to something negative, or that will lead others to say something negative about the person.

What could be wrong with praising someone?

Plenty, according to the Chofetz Chaim.

Never praise someone in front of people who dislike him, for they are bound to find something uncomplimentary to say about the person.

Never praise someone excessively to anyone. When you gush with praise about someone, the listener is likely to respond, “Yes, it’s all true, but no one’s perfect, and I happen to know that …”

Never praise someone (even in a non-excessive way) in front of a crowd, because quite possibly at least one person present will point out something negative about that individual.

An exception to this rule is when the speaker is discussing a renowned tzaddik. For example, it would be perfectly correct to sing the praises of the late Rosh Yeshivah of Mesivta Torah Vodaath, Rabbi Avraham Pam, for no one would have anything negative to say about him.

The Chofetz Chaim cautions: Reuven should not initiate a conversation with Shimon about Levi if he knows that Shimon and Levi are not on the best of terms. In such a case, there is a reasonable possibility that Shimon will say something negative about Levi.

In Be’er Mayim Chaim, the Chofetz Chaim goes a step further: If someone is a party in a case in beis din, it is best not to ask him how the court ruled. This is because if the court ruled against him, he might bear a grudge against the dayanim (judges) and say something negative about them. Thus, asking him about the ruling might lead to the great sin of disparaging talmidei chachamim.

IN A NUTSHELL

Before praising someone, consider whom you are speaking to and how great the praise is.

In conversation with others, do not mention names of those towards whom they may have bad feelings.

 -A project of  Mesorah Publications –

Categories
Daily Companion

The Perils of Praise

In this segment, the Chofetz Chaim begins addressing the subject of avak loshon hora (lit. the dust of loshon hora), statements which are not actual loshon hora but which are nonetheless forbidden.

The mere concept of avak loshon hora underscores the severity of loshon hora. This sin is so dangerous that an entire chapter of Sefer Chofetz Chaim is devoted to statements which are forbidden because they hint at loshon hora or because they can lead to loshon hora.

A particle of dust is so miniscule that one has to look very carefully to see it at all. It is often the same with avak loshon hora. One may be dealing with words which seem quite innocuous. In the Chofetz Chaim’s first example, someone comments about a certain person, “It’s amazing how far he’s come.” On the surface, it appears that the speaker has not spoken derogatorily about his subject, nor caused him any harm. But if we probe a bit further, we can expand the statement to mean, “It’s amazing how far he’s come, considering the fact that he has an unsavory past,” or “… considering the fact that he’s not that bright.” In all probability, the speaker’s intention was entirely complimentary. Nevertheless, people may lose respect for the person, no matter what his current status, if they find out that he had a troubled past or if they perceive him as lacking in intelligence.

Perhaps the most famous case of avak loshon hora is when the statement is pure praise of an individual. On the surface, this would seem to pose no problem. What could be wrong with praising someone? To understand the problem we need to examine the dynamics of a conversation. In conversation, each person builds on what the other person has just said. The halachah identifies certain conversations as being likely to lead toloshon hora and declares them forbidden.

In certain situations, praising an individual can lead listeners to focus on the flaws of the person being praised. One is not allowed to praise someone in front of his enemies. The temptation is overwhelming to rebut praise of one’s enemy with criticism.

We should never praise someone excessively, even to his friends. When the spotlight is directed onto someone and his praises are sung, it is quite possible that someone will say, “Yes, he has many fine qualities — except for the fact that…”

We have been discussing praising someone in front of one person or a few people. One should not praise someone in public, says the Chofetz Chaim. This is because the law of averages dictates that there will be at least one person who either is jealous of the person or has something against him—in which case the praise is sure to set off a negative reaction. The only situation where public praise is allowed is when the subject is renowned as a learned, righteous person. In such a case it is reasonable to assume that even if he has critics, they will be reluctant to speak out publicly against him, because by doing so they would lose their own credibility.

Yet in Be’er Mayim Chaim the Chofetz Chaim says that we should avoid sitting amongpeople who are discussing a renowned Torah personality, because there are some people who simply cannot resist offering criticism no matter who the subject is. As we discussed, negative talk about such an individual is a most serious sin, as is listening to and accepting it.

Categories
Shmiras Haloshon

Give Me a Hint!

Categories
30 Seconds to Proper Speech Proper Speech

Serious Threats

The Torah commands us: “Do not stand aside while your fellow’s blood is being shed (Vayikra 19:16)”. We are obligated to spare no effort in preventing our fellow Jew from suffering physical, emotional, or monetary damage.

In a situation where a potential victim is unaware that he is being threatened, one is required to warn him even though this will reflect negatively on the person or persons responsible. Speech of this sort is not merely permissible, it is obligatory. Nevertheless, one must be certain that conditions which render speech constructive have been appropriately met (see Days 42-50).

Categories
Family Lesson a Day

Between Parents and Children

SEFER CHOFETZ CHAIM — Hilchos Lashon Hara 8:13-14

It is told that a chasid once came to his rebbe and said, “Please, Rebbe, give me a berachah that my children should want to study Torah.” The rebbe replied, “I suggest that if you want your children to learn, you yourself should begin to learn. Otherwise, your children will grow up the same way as you, and they will one day come to me for a berachah that their children should want to learn …”

The point of the story is that children imitate what they see. The Chofetz Chaim says that the same applies to instructing children to avoid lashon hara. If parents set a proper example and are careful to avoid speaking lashon hara, then they can demand of their children to do the same. If, however, parents regularly speak against others and then tell their children, “Stop speaking lashon hara!” their words will have little effect.

If a father tells his child, “Mr. Stone, that fellow who sits next to me in shul, is not a very nice person,” the child is not permitted to believe it, just as he may not believe such lashon hara from anyone. What the child should do is tell his father privately, “I do not mean to be disrespectful, but could it be that what you told me about the man in shul was actually lashon hara?” It is a great mitzvah to point this out to the parent, so that hopefully he will be more careful with his words in the future.

The Torah states:” Rebuke your fellow Jew and do not bear a sin because of him.” It is a mitzvah and an obligation to try to correct another Jew’s sinful behavior. Our Sages learn from the words, “And do not bear a sin because of him,” that we should not sin in the manner in which we offer criticism. This means that though we have to criticize a sinner and point out his mistakes, we should not sin by embarrassing him. Rather, we should address him respectfully and preferably in private. This applies any time we must point out someone’s sins.

Surely this is true when pointing out a parent’s sins. If parents are speaking lashon hara, we must try to stop them. The Chofetz Chaim states that if we remain silent, we will be held accountable in Heaven for permitting them to continue to commit this terrible sin. At the same time, we must be very careful to address them with the utmost respect. We must speak to them in a way that makes clear our great love and respect for our father and mother, who brought us into this world and do far more for us than we can ever repay.

IN A NUTSHELL

We are not permitted to listen to lashon hara spoken by our parents. It is a great mitzvah to respectfully ask parents to refrain from speak­ing lashon hara.

 -A project of  Mesorah Publications –

Categories
Daily Companion

Safeguarding One’s Surroundings

Our sages teach that all Jews are responsible for one another (Shevuos 39b). That responsibility has an impact on the laws of shmiras haloshon as well. The Chofetz Chaim teaches us that to the extent that we can influence others to observe these all-important laws, we are responsible to do so.

He uses the example of a man who stands at the head of his household. His responsibility in the area of shmiras haloshon extends to his wife and children. Certainly a mother, too, must actively educate and correct her family members regarding shmiras haloshon. The Chofetz Chaim cites a Talmudic teaching that one who has the ability to chastise the members of his household, but refrains from doing so, will be held responsible for their deeds (Shabbos 54b). A parent’s responsibility is awesome.

Let no one think, however, that this is the charge of parents alone. Every Jew must seek to eradicate the sin of loshon hora from his surroundings. The Chofetz Chaim states that children should not allow loshon hora spoken by their parents to go unnoticed. Of course, parents must be addressed with sensitivity and great respect. Often, a rav (rabbi) should be consulted regarding the proper approach to use. The Chofetz Chaim stresses that children who choose to turn a blind eye to their parents’ loshon hora will be held responsible, as will their parents.

There is one overriding rule to bear in mind whenever rebuke is in order. Speak gently, says the Chofetz Chaim. To turn our homes into battlefields will only be counterproductive. Gentle reproof is the only formula for achieving positive results.

The Chofetz Chaim has one final piece of advice. As the saying goes, “The apple doesn’t fall far from the tree.” Children learn most from observing their parents’ behavior. It is crucial that parents set a good example by avoiding all forms of forbidden speech in conversation. Then, their children will see shmiras haloshon as a way of life.

Our children’s Torah education is our national treasure. Parents make great personal sacrifices to pay for Torah education, driven by the yearning that their children should grow to be Jews who are devoted to Hashem and His Torah. To a great extent, the education of our children takes place within the confines of our homes. If we live according to the Torah’s teachings in all areas of life, then we can expect that our children will follow in our footsteps, in their relationship with Hashem and with their fellow man.

Categories
Shmiras Haloshon

How to Exert Your Influence

Categories
30 Seconds to Proper Speech Proper Speech

Verbal Abuse

It is permissible to speak negatively about someone who was guilty of verbal abuse, in order to comfort his victim. The pain and humiliation caused by insulting speech can be minimized by pointing out to the victim that the perpetrator lacks intelligence or discretion and that people do not take him seriously.

At a later point in time, it would be important to help the victim understand the nature and problems of the perpetrator so that he can learn how to deal with the person and prevent recurrence of such incidents.

Categories
Family Lesson a Day

A Great Chillul Hashem

SEFER CHOFETZ CHAIM — Hilchos Lashon Hara 8:12

In his preface, the Chofetz Chaim taught that whenever a person speaks lashon hara, he is guilty of chillul Hashem. The chillul Hashem is due to his lack of regard for the Torah’s prohibition against speaking lashon hara.

Just as there are various levels of kiddush Hashem, so too are there various levels of chillul Hashem. When a Jew speaks negatively about his fellow Jew before non-Jews, his sin is particularly severe. When a Jew speaks badly of a Jew before other Jews, there is a reasonable possibility that his listeners will not accept his words as fact. After all, why should they believe something negative about a fellow Jew, especially since they know that the speaker is sinning by issuing his report?

A non-Jew, however, will probably be quick to believe anything negative that one Jew has to say about another. Aside from this, says the Chofetz Chaim, when a Jew speaks badly about Jews to non-Jews, he is desecrating Hashem’s Name.

Think about it: What might go through a non-Jew’s mind when he hears Jews speaking badly of other Jews? “After all these years of suffering and persecution, these Jews still can’t get along. My goodness, all those nasty things he said about that fellow — and more! Where is their loyalty to each other? Aren’t they the ones who preach about loving your fellow as your very own self?”

Rabbeinu Yonah, one of the great Rishonim (Early Commentators), writes that other than death, there is only one way to atone for the terrible sin of chillul Hashem. Someone who has brought disgrace upon Hashem’s Name can be forgiven through kiddush Hashem, bringing glory to His Name.1 A person who has spoken lashon hara about Jews to non-Jews and wishes to repent should make a special effort to show the world the greatness of Torah and the beauty of its ways. As our Sages teach:

“And you shall love Hashem, your G-d”2 — that the Name of Heaven should become beloved through you. A person should study Torah, be honest in his dealings, and speak pleasantly to people. What will people say of him? Fortunate is his father who taught him Torah, fortunate is his teacher who taught him Torah. This person who studied Torah — how pleasant are his deeds, how correct are his ways …

The Chofetz Chaim also discusses the tragedy of a moser, informer. A Jew who informs on his fellow Jews to non-Jews, and thereby brings suffering and misery upon them, is a grave sinner who may never be able to fully repent for his sins. Of such a person, the Chofetz Chaim says “His sin is too great to bear.” This expression, borrowed from Parashas Bereishis, where Kayin murders his brother, Hevel, shows us the seriousness of the sin of malshinus, informing.

IN A NUTSHELL

The sin of speaking lashon hara about a Jew to a non-Jew is particularly severe and is a great chillul Hashem.

The sin of a moser (informer) is too great to bear.

 -A project of  Mesorah Publications –

Categories
Daily Companion

To a Non-Jew

At one time or another, we hear derogatory remarks about Jews. It is tragic enough when such remarks are made by Jews to Jewish listeners. Even more tragic is when they are told by Jews to co-workers or business associates who are not Jewish. The subject of these remarks might be an individual Jew, a specific group of Jews, or Jews in general.

The Chofetz Chaim declares that to speak loshon hora about a Jew when the listener is a gentile is a much greater sin than when the listener is a Jew. One who is guilty of this sin “ disgraces the honor of Israel and desecrates the Name of Heaven.”

There is yet another reason for the particular severity of this sin. When one speaks loshon hora to a fellow Jew, there is a possibility that the listener will not be quick to accept the report as fact—especially if he is someone familiar with the laws of loshon hora. Gentiles, on the other hand, certainly do not have a predisposition towards judging Jews favorably. Upon hearing the derogatory report, the gentile will be quick to believe it and pass the information on to others.

When a Jew denigrates other Jews in the presence of gentiles, he is, in essence, contradicting the purpose of his own existence. Our mission in this world as a people is to spread the honor of Hashem by serving as His representatives before the rest of the world. We say in Shema each day: “V’Ahavta es Hashem Elokecha” And you shall love Hashem, your God (Devarim 6:4). Our Sages teach (Yoma 86a) that we demonstrate our love of Hashem by making His Name beloved in the eyes of others. When a Jew studies Torah, speaks pleasantly to people and deals honestly in business, then people say, “ Praiseworthy is the father who taught him Torah; praiseworthy is the teacher who taught him Torah. See how beautiful and correct are his ways and deeds.”

Thus the damage caused by relating loshon hora to gentiles goes far beyond loshon hora, which is devastating in itself. Instead of using his abilities to increase Hashem’s honor, the speaker has been guilty of chillul Hashem (desecration of Hashem’s Name).

Categories
Shmiras Haloshon

Do You Qualify for the Job?

Categories
30 Seconds to Proper Speech Proper Speech

Psychological And Emotional Damage

An important area of speech which is considered constructive is that which helps to relieve someone of psychological or emotional damage caused by others.

It is permissible for anyone who is suffering emotionally or psychologically to seek appropriate help even if this involves discussions of people and events that would otherwise constitute loshon hora. If possible, names should be omitted, and only pertinent information should be shared.

The Chofetz Chaim speculates that it may be considered constructive for a person troubled by an issue to unburden himself to someone even if only to relieve himself of stress. Obviously, this applies to especially difficult situations and not to the daily vicissitudes of life.

Categories
Family Lesson a Day

In the Family II

SEFER CHOFETZ CHAIM — Hilchos Lashon Hara 8:10-11

In Pirkei Avos, Yosei ben Yochanan teaches: “Do not speak excessively with a woman. They said this about one’s wife; surely it applies to someone else’s wife …”

Avos d’R’ Nosson elaborates upon this teaching. A man should not come home from work or the beis midrash and tell his wife lashon hara about people whom he finds difficult. As the Chofetz Chaim notes, when someone does not follow this halachah and vents to his wife every time he is upset with someone, the result will be not only lashon hara, but machlokes as well. His wife will be upset at that person, she will encourage her husband to “stand his ground,” and might very well vent her anger at the other person the next time she meets him.

The importance of this halachah cannot be overstated. There are those who mistakenly think that because husbands and wives are so close, the laws of shemiras halashon do not apply to them. They erroneously believe that they may share with each other anything that happens in their dealings with others. The above mishnah tells us that this is incorrect. Whatever I cannot tell to my neighbor or friend, I cannot tell to my wife or any other close relative.

There is an exception to this rule. It is obvious that if a child is having a problem with a classmate who is bullying him, he should discuss this with his rebbi, menahel or parents. This falls under the category of lashon hara l’to’eles, lashon hara that is spoken for a constructive purpose. Similarly, if, for example, a woman is being tormented by her boss or fellow employee and she needs to share her pain with someone, she would be allowed to discuss the matter with her husband.

A husband may also tell his wife not to do business with someone whom he knows to be dishonest. Even if he has only heard that the person is dishonest but has not confirmed it, he can warn his wife to be careful, though neither he nor his wife can believe the information as fact.

It is forbidden to tell lashon hara to someone about that person’s relative. For example, if Yosef and Asher are brothers, it is forbidden to tell Yosef, “Boy, did Asher get into trouble today. He …” If the person wants to convince Asher to correct his behavior, he should speak to him directly. If this attempt is unsuccessful, and the person believes that Asher would accept criticism from his brother Yosef, he would be permitted to speak to Yosef.

The same applies to a father and son. One should not tell a father about his son’s misbehavior without first attempting to speak to the son directly, if speaking to him has a chance at succeeding.

IN A NUTSHELL

We are not permitted to speak lashon hara to our close relatives, nor are we permitted to speak lashon hara to someone about his relative.

 -A project of  Mesorah Publications –

Categories
Daily Companion

Between Husband and Wife

The Chofetz Chaim now turns his focus in a different direction —to whom am I forbidden to relate loshon hora? He answers, “ There is no difference regarding this prohibition, whether the listener is one’s relative or someone distant, or even one’s own wife — unless it is something of which he must inform her for a constructive purpose.”

The Chofetz Chaim focuses on a very typical situation. A husband comes home and his wife asks, “ How was your day?” or, “ What’s new in shul (synagogue)?” The Chofetz Chaim cautions us strongly against using such questions as a forum for telling one’s wife of any arguments or other unpleasant encounters which he had during the course of the day. Not only is this loshon hora, but it does further damage, since the wife, out of loyalty to her husband, is likely to harbor animosity towards the person whom the husband feels has wronged him. This may lead to her finding the opportunity to castigate the man or his family members, so that a situation which could have been resolved will instead become a full-scale feud between families.

The Chofetz Chaim adds a bit of marital advice. He says that if a husband habitually complains to his wife about the slights and indignities which he perceives have been heaped upon him, then he actually lowers himself in her eyes. She begins to believe that others do not respect him, and that perhaps he is not really worthy of respect. The Chofetz Chaim quotes Avos D’Rabbi Nassan (7:3) which explains the words of the Mishnah, “ Do not speak excessively with a woman,” as making exactly this point; excessive complaining to his wife lowers a man’s esteem in her eyes.

The Chofetz Chaim points out that there are clearly cases of toeles (constructive purpose) where spouses are allowed to, and ought to, share information. This applies to business partnerships, as well. Certainly one partner can warn the other about problems with a potential vendor or customer. However, one must be careful to release only that negative information which is absolutely essential.

If it is possible to solve the problem without saying anything negative, then that is the strategy required. For example, your wife says, “ Mrs. Klein invited us to dinner next week.” But you have reason to believe that the kashrus level in the Klein’s house does not meet your standards. To avoid speaking loshon hora you should think of some benign reason for declining the invitation. If your wife finds your excuse unreasonable and is upset, then you may tell her your real reason.

In truth, there are many ways to protect a spouse, business associate or oneself from harmful people or situations without resorting to loshon hora. Although it might take a little effort or ingenuity, our Sages assure us that the dividends will surely be well worth our while.

Categories
Shmiras Haloshon

Between Husband and Wife

Categories
30 Seconds to Proper Speech Proper Speech

The Rights Of The Victim

We have seen (Days 63-66) that even when it is clear to someone that one person has wronged another financially, he may not attempt to effect justice outside the confines of halachah. This applies not only to a witness, but also to the victim himself.

If one feels that he has fallen victim to another person’s dishonesty, and after verifying the facts concludes that he has a valid claim against that person, he must not publicly speak against that person for the sake of attaining restitution. Rather, he should confront the individual privately and, if necessary, consult a rav. If possible, the name of the accused should not be mentioned.

A witness may not divulge to the victim the identity of the perpetrator, if the victim could be expected to employ halachically unacceptable tactics to retrieve his money.

Categories
Daily Companion

Putting Out the Fire

In this segment, the Chofetz Chaim discusses the issue of loshon hora as it relates to machlokes (dispute). Specifically, he deals with how and when to speak up regarding a controversy with the intention of quelling the dispute and making peace.

The danger of becoming involved in any dispute is that it is often difficult to know which side is right. What one side sees as a valid complaint, the other may see as nonsense. As the saying goes, “There are two sides to every story.”

How, then, does one handle this kind of situation? The Chofetz Chaim cautions us, “Ponder the matter carefully, in accordance with the laws of the Torah and [only then] decide which side is the baal machlokes (instigator of strife).” Apparently, the Chofetz Chaim is telling us to consult someone whois learned and, with his guidance, sift slowly and carefully through the information to determine if one of the disputants can be classified as a baal machlokes.

This is not an easy task. The Chofetz Chaim says that if, after examining the situation carefully, we cannot determine which side is guilty, then we should refrain from becoming involved.

If, on the other hand, we have determined that one of the parties is a baal machlokes, then the Torah allows us to publicly voice our condemnation of this person as a means of convincing him to end the dispute. We are speaking specifically in a case where the baal machlokes will most likely back away from the battle when he realizes that public opinion is against him. On the other hand, if this person is impervious to public opinion, then there is no constructive purpose in publicly declaring him a baal machlokes, and doing so would constitute speaking loshon hora.

The Chofetz Chaim lists three additional prerequisites before one speaks against a baal machlokes:

1. One must have accurate firsthand information regarding the dispute.

2. One’s intention must be strictly for a constructive purpose and not because he happens to dislike this person. If a previous animosity exists, one is not allowed to become involved. This point will be clarified later in this volume (see Day 83).

3. Obviously, if one can speak privately to the baal machlokes and convince him to desist, then that is the path which one is required to take. However, the Chofetz Chaim recognizes that in the case of the baal machlokes, rebuke may be a double-edged sword. By rebuking him in private one may lose his status as an impartial party and become aligned in the instigator’s mind with his enemies. The instigator may then move quickly to thwart any attempts to rebuke him publicly. If this scenario seems to be a real possibility, then one should not attempt to rebuke the baal machlokes in private.

Categories
Shmiras Haloshon

3 Conditions for Speaking Up

Categories
30 Seconds to Proper Speech Proper Speech

Accusations Against the Beis Din

If one witnessed a crime which subsequently came before abeis din, rabbinical court, and the accused was acquitted of any wrongdoing, it is forbidden to voice criticism of the beis din’s ruling. One must assume that a court comprised of Torah scholars has done its best to ascertain the facts according to the methods prescribed by halachah (i.e. testimony of two valid witnesses), and has ruled in accordance with Jewish law as detailed in Shulchan Aruch. If one was the sole witness to a crime, then his testimony is invalid, no matter how convincing are his arguments. Furthermore, one must come to terms with the reality that humans are limited in their ability to determine and carry out absolute justice, and ultimately, it is in Hashem’s power to correct social justice.

Certainly one who loses a court case cannot possibly be objective in his evaluation of the beis din’s ruling. The practice of raising questions as to the competence of the beis din, or accusing the judges of bias, is blatant hotzaas shem ra (slander).

Nevertheless, if one suspects that the ruling was the result of an error in the legal process, he could seek the advice of a rabbinic authority and ask that he investigate the matter.

Categories
Family Lesson a Day

Ends of the Spectrum

SEFER CHOFETZ CHAIM — Hilchos Lashon Hara 8:4-7

The Gemara tells us, “Even the empty ones among you are filled with mitzvos like the seeds of a pomegranate.”1 Every Jew is deserving of our concern and respect. The fact that someone is ignorant of Torah does not give us the right to speak of him in a derogatory way.

The Chofetz Chaim lived in a time when thousands of Jewish young men and women were being swept away by the winds of Socialism, Communism, and other secular movements. Tragically, some of the leaders of these movements were raised in religious homes and not only left the Torah path, but tried very hard to influence others to join them. The Chofetz Chaim labels these people apikorsim (heretics), and he derives from the Torah that it is permissible to speak lashon hara about them. As we have already mentioned, it is correct to speak badly of someone who is a bad influence, in the hope that this will convince others to stay far away from him and his sinful ideas.

At the other end of the spectrum is the talmid chacham, who represents the Torah and therefore is deserving of special respect. The Gemara labels as “foolish” those who rise in respect for a sefer Torah (as the halachah requires) but do not rise for a talmid chacham.

Speaking lashon hara about a talmid chacham is a particularly grave sin.

The Chofetz Chaim discusses a false attitude that people sometimes have. “Why must I respect him?” they argue. “You consider him a talmid chacham? Had he lived in the days of the Rambam, he would not be considered a talmid chacham at all!”

This is wrong, for we judge a person’s scholarship according to the level of his generation. “Yiftach [HaGiladi] in his generation is like Shmuel [HaNavi] in his generation.” Each generation must revere and obey their Torah leaders in the same way that earlier generations revered theirs.

Rabbi Chaim Shmulevitz added another insight. In each generation, Hashem places Torah leaders who are appropriate for that time. The leaders of later generations may not be on the level of those of earlier times, but their personalities and qualities are what their generation needs. For this, too, they should be accorded the highest respect.

When people do not show rabbanim and roshei yeshivah proper respect, the Torah is disgraced and the community’s spiritual level is lowered. Megillas Rus opens with words which our Sages interpret to mean, “And it was in the days when the judges were judged.” This sort of climate, when leaders are being judged and criticized by the masses, leads to disrespect, sin and, ultimately, destruction.

IN A NUTSHELL

We must respect even those who are ignorant of Torah.

To speak against a talmid chacham is a particularly grave sin.

 -A project of  Mesorah Publications –

Categories
Daily Companion

Torah Scholars

This segment begins with the Chofetz Chaim informing us of how terrible it is to speak loshon hora about a talmid chacham (Torah scholar).

Obviously, we are obligated to honor Torah scholars, and speaking loshon hora is certainly not according them honor. But there is something even more serious at stake. When one speaks loshon hora about a talmid chacham, the underlying message is that the scholar’s flaw disqualifies him from rendering a sound opinion. The speaker of loshon hora is actually saying, “We don’t have to listen to him.” The influence of his wicked words may cause others to say to themselves: “Why should we seek the opinion of this rav? He’s not great enough to come up with the right answer. We might as well just figure things out for ourselves.”

The Chofetz Chaim gives us a helpful insight into the strategy which the yetzer hara uses to entice someone into speaking against a talmid chacham. “It’s true,” says the yetzer hara, “that you should not shame a talmid chacham, but that’s not a problem nowadays. Only in earlier generations, when a Torah scholar was on an exceedingly high level, was shaming a Torah scholar a serious sin. But nowadays, when scholars know so much less, it’s no longer an issue.”

The Chofetz Chaim informs us that this is patently false; the criteria by which we judge whether someone is to be considered a talmid chacham are based on the level of the generation. Anyone who has attained the status of rav (rabbi), dayan (judge), or posek (one who renders halachic rulings) is certainly in the category of a talmid chacham, and speaking loshon hora of him is a very serious sin.

Of course, we are forbidden to speak loshon hora even about an am ha’aretz, someone devoid of Torah knowledge. It is only regarding an apikoros (heretic) that we are permitted to speak loshon hora. This will be discussed in the next segment.

The laws of shmiras haloshon underscore the profound impact which our words have on our relationships with family, neighbors and friends, and the respect which our rabbis and Torah teachers should enjoy within the community. This realization should inspire us to conduct all our dealings and conversations with the care and concern which the Torah requires of us. If we accomplish this, we will serve as a catalyst for elevating our society, and as the “light unto the nations” which Hashem has chosen us to be.

Categories
Shmiras Haloshon

Why Should We Seek His Opinion?

Categories
Shmiras Haloshon

It’s a Mitzvah to Speak About Him!

Categories
30 Seconds to Proper Speech Proper Speech

Taking The Law Into One’s Hands

We have seen that it is permissible for a beis din, rabbinical court, to use certain forms of social pressure to persuade an individual to abide by its ruling. However, it is forbidden to use social pressure in order to bypass the court process and force a thief to return what he stole. It is wrong to cause the community to take a stand in a monetary issue on the basis of an individual’s word alone; only through the psak (ruling) of a beis din may the community take a stand. Thus, it is correct to ensure that the parties come before a beis din, but it is forbidden to personally orchestrate the enforcement of what one believes to be justice.

Categories
Family Lesson a Day

Children

SEFER CHOFETZ CHAIM — Hilchos Lashon Hara 8:3

Once, Rabbi Moshe Feinstein was visiting a family on yom tov when he heard a baby cry­ing. The family was so enthralled by the visit of this Torah giant that they ignored the baby’s cries. Seeing this, R’ Moshe said to them, “It is yom tov for the baby too.” R’ Moshe was saying that though a baby cannot communicate his feelings, he is a person and his cries are the cries of a person who is upset — and should not be ignored.

Rabbi Avraham Pam made a similar point. He spoke of the common practice of adults to take away a child’s toy for “fun.” The adult hides the toy behind his back and then has the child guess which hand the toy is in. The adult switches the toy from one hand to the other as the child becomes more and more upset. Rav Pam said that just as it is forbidden to make an adult upset, so too it is forbidden to make a young child upset.

Regarding lashon hara, just as we cannot make statements that might cause harm to an adult, so too, with children. The Chofetz Chaim offers an example of an orphan who is being raised by people who took him into their home as a kindness. If someone witnesses this child fighting with other children, he has to be very careful about relating this to the child’s benefactors. They may decide that if this how the child behaves, then they don’t want him in their home.

Of course, this does not mean that such a child should be free to do whatever he pleases. What it does mean is that before relating such information, one should be absolutely sure that all seven rules of lashon hara l’to’eles (for a constructive purpose) have been met. Before relating such information, the person must carefully consider the outcome. If the result would be an injustice to the child, then some other way should be sought to correct the child’s behavior.

The fact that words can build or destroy is especially true regarding children. Rav Pam would tell of the time a father of one of his talmidim came to inquire about his son’s progress. Rav Pam was truthful, as the halachah requires. He said that the boy was learning, but was not meet­ing his potential.

The father said, “Really? I’m going to call him over right now!”

Rav Pam’s heart sank, because it sounded as if the father was going to give his son a real tongue-lashing.

The boy came over and the father said to him, “Your rebbi said that you are doing nicely, and it needs to be just a bit better. So let’s see that ‘little bit extra’ and then you’ll really be terrific!”

The boy beamed with pleasure. His learning improved and he went on to become a respected talmid chacham and teacher of Torah.

IN A NUTSHELL

We cannot relate information about children that might cause them harm. If they have misbehaved, the rules of to’eles (constructive pur­pose) must be met before relating this information.

 -A project of  Mesorah Publications –

Categories
Daily Companion

Children

It is forbidden to speak derogatorily about children.* While adults understand that “kids are kids” and their negative behavior is often excused as normal immaturity, if the information casts this particular child in a bad light it should not be spoken or listened to. The Chofetz Chaim stresses that it is also forbidden to mention something about a child which is not derogatory but is harmful. The example offered is where someone mentions something negative about a child in the presence of his foster parents. While the information is not derogatory and may describe behavior common to children, it may make the foster parents unwilling to care for this child. The Chofetz Chaim notes that sometimes children can be punished excessively by their natural parents because of information about their behavior which angered the parent. Therefore, one should exercise caution before relating any such information.

From their end, parents and teachers should be careful not to discipline children based on negative reports without following the basic rule for acceptance of loshon hora: the parent or teacher must first investigate the report and determine that it is accurate. Only then can he or she take action.

Rabbi Avraham Pam z”l, used to tell the story of a young child who was punished when an item was found in his knapsack which a fellow classmate had been missing. The apparent culprit insisted that he had not stolen the item and that he had no idea how it had gotten into his knapsack. The teacher refused to believe him and punished him by having him wear a sign which read, “I am a thief.” A long time passed before another boy came along and admitted that he had stolen the item. He had wanted to return it but was too ashamed to admit his guilt, so he stuffed the item into another boy’s knapsack.

An innocent child was humiliated publicly because his teacher immediately accepted the evidence and ignored the child’s protests. If this could happen in a case where the evidence seemed so convincing, how careful must we be not to take action based on reports without first investigating the matter.

Categories
Shmiras Haloshon

It’s not Child’s Play!

Categories
30 Seconds to Proper Speech Proper Speech

Initiating A Din Torah

The Torah requires that monetary disputes be adjudicated by a beis din, rabbinical court. It is permissible to exert social pressure on an individual to convince him to agree to participate in a din Torah (court case) before a beis din. However, social pressure that could cause embarrassment is not an option if the person is in the category of amisecha, your fellow (see Day 55). A person who erroneously believes that he is justified in taking someone else’s money must be set straight, but he is not a mumar (rebellious sinner). Embarrassment is not a recourse, but one may discuss the matter with anyone who can influence the person and explain that the person is involved in a monetary dispute and should be persuaded to come before a beis din.

Unlike an individual, a beis din may publicize the fact that an individual refuses to abide by its ruling or has ignored a summons to appear before it. As previously mentioned, social pressure is often the only means by which rabbinical courts can enforce their decision.

Categories
Family Lesson a Day

In the Family

SEFER CHOFETZ CHAIM — Hilchos Rechilus 7:1

In Hilchos Lashon Hara, we learned that the laws of proper speech are in force within the family no less than outside the family. A husband has no right to tell lashon hara to his wife, nor can a child tell lashon hara to his or her parent — unless the rules of to’eles have been met.

The same applies to the laws of rechilus.

The girls were having a cake sale in school to raise funds for tzedakah. When Chavi displayed her marble cake, Rina said, “My mother said that you would bring in a marble cake — it’s the only cake your mother bakes that comes out good!”

Chavi was very hurt by this thoughtless, hurtful comment.

Chavi would be wrong to repeat Rina’s comment to anyone — especially her mother. Chavi’s mother would surely be hurt by the comment, probably even more than Chavi. Furthermore, the comment has the potential to cause bad feelings and even a feud between the two women. Thus, repeating it would be a transgression of the laws of rechilus.

If Rina’s mother did make the comment, she quite possibly did not mean anything nasty. She might be a perfectionist, whose baked goods are picture-perfect, exactly as they appear in a magazine. Chavi’s mother bakes good, tasty cakes, but they don’t have that professional look — except for her marble cake.

Sometimes, a fairly innocent comment can be repeated in a way that gives a very bad impression, and may be the spark that ignites a terrible dispute.

Parents are very protective of their children, and rightfully so. It is for this reason that one must be very careful before telling parents that someone else’s child harmed their child in some way. The Chofetz Chaim notes that it is forbidden to speak rechilus about children, and he adds that problems of this sort often happen in shul.

Zalman Kochlefel loves excitement. If all is calm and peaceful, Zalman finds a way to stir up trouble.

On a quiet Shabbos afternoon during Shalosh Seudos, Zalman runs into shul and announces breathlessly, “Isaac, your son is really get­ting it from that Goldman kid. I tried to break up the fight, but the kid ignored me.”

Isaac is a hot-tempered man, a fact that Zalman knows very well. With Nachman Goldman not far behind, Isaac dashes out of the shul, grabs hold of young Chezky Goldman and lifts him into the air. “Don’t you ever touch my son again!” he bellows, before putting the frightened child down.

Chesky’s father runs up to Isaac and shouts, “You ever touch my son again, I’ll have you thrown out of this kehillah.”
Thus began a feud that never ended.
Zalman had his wish.

A fight between children is not that difficult to stop. If Zalman had cared to do the right thing, he could have approached others for help. The hot-tempered father should have been the last one to be called.

Someone who is truly interested in peace will be on guard not to fan the flames of strife.

IN A NUTSHELL

We may not speak rechilus to family members, and we should be wary of relating information to those who are hot-tempered or prone to quarrel.

 -A project of  Mesorah Publications –

Categories
Shmiras Haloshon

How to Keep the Peace in the Family

Categories
30 Seconds to Proper Speech Proper Speech

Informing

The second category of constructive purpose is to help those who are being (or have been) adversely affected by the subject’s behavior.

If one has personally witnessed a Jew causing monetary damage to another, to ensure that the victim will be compensated is a constructive purpose. It would therefore be permissible to relate what has transpired. After ascertaining that the facts are correct, and after having spoken with the perpetrator, one must determine what will result from relating the information and whether or not halachah justifies effecting that result.

In a civilized society, the straightforward way of dealing with crime is to inform the authorities. However, reporting one’s fellow Jew to secular officials may result in his facing punishment undeserved according to Torah. Imprisonment, for example, is not an acceptable means of punishment for monetary infractions, by Torah standards. Providing information that might lead to a Jew’s imprisonment could therefore constitute malshinus (the act of being a malshin, informer). Only if it is clear that an individual is dangerous and poses a threat to others can he be spoken against for the sake of protecting others from harm. Such matters are extremely sensitive and complex, and demand consultation with a competent halachic authority.

Categories
Family Lesson a Day

A Tragic Error

SEFER CHOFETZ CHAIM — Hilchos Lashon Hara 7:13-14

It happened once that Rabbi Avraham Pam was asked to preside over a din Torah [Jewish court case] between two distinguished parties. The din Torah was to be held in Rav Pam’s yeshivah office.

Two people who were on one side of the dispute arrived first and approached Rav Pam at his seat in the beis midrash, where he was engrossed in learning. When Rav Pam noticed the two men, both well known in the community, he did not even nod in greeting. He simply stood up and led them to the office where the din Torah would be held.

A few minutes later, the members of the other side arrived. Upon hearing that their opponents had preceded them and were in the “courtroom” together with Rav Pam, one of them exclaimed, “Oh, no! That means they had a chance to tell Rav Pam their side of the story without our having a chance to respond!” A talmid of Rav Pam responded, “I am sure that my rebbi would not allow them to say a word before the other side is present in the room.” He was right.

Resolving disputes requires wisdom, patience, and, most of all, impartiality. A judge or mediator who even slightly favors one side in an argument has no right to judge the case. In this segment, the Chofetz Chaim bemoans a situation that could happen in a community whose leaders wield considerable power.

… Many people make a mistake in these matters. If something is stolen from them and they suspect a certain individual, they tell the community leaders that they have strong evidence against that individual. The leaders, in turn, punish that person in an attempt to get him

to confess. This is contrary to halachah. Even if devarim nicarim (see previous segment) are acceptable as proof, nevertheless, these leaders need to determine that indeed there was a robbery (as the person claims); and they need witnesses who can vouch that the evidence is true, or determine for themselves that the evidence is true. They have no right to rely on the claimant and punish a Jew without cause. Even to believe in one’s heart that what the claimant said is true is forbidden, because of the prohibition against believing lashon hara …

Those who act in this way do so out of ignorance of the halachah; and out of prejudice towards the accused, whom they have decided is guilty without real proof. This is not the Torah way. We assume a person to be honest unless there is real proof to the contrary that we know firsthand to be true. We also have to be absolutely certain that there is no way to give the person the benefit of the doubt so that his actions can be inter­preted in a positive way.

IN A NUTSHELL

Community leaders are not permitted to accept one person’s accusations against another without valid testimony or concrete proof.

 -A project of  Mesorah Publications –

Categories
Daily Companion

Monetary Disputes

If you have ever been approached by a person involved in a monetary dispute, you have probably found that in his opinion, his opponent is completely in the wrong with no justification at all for his position. Quite possibly, if you spoke to the other party you would encounter a reasonable person whose claims against the first party are equally valid. The fact is that in financial disputes, there often are no villains. Rather, there are misunderstandings and conditions that were never properly clarified from the start. However, it is natural for the disputants to view matters solely from their own perspectives. This fact can lead to major problems when disputants offer what they consider to be obvious proof before a beis din (rabbinical court).

The Chofetz Chaim provides the following rule: A beis din can make use of such proof only if they can personally vouch for the validity of the proof or if two witnesses testified in beis din to the validity of the proof. In such a case beis din is allowed to actually punish the defendant based on the proof provided.

The Chofetz Chaim bemoans the fact that all too often, a party brings his monetary complaints to leaders of his community, offering circumstantial evidence, and the community leaders take action based on his word alone. The Chofetz Chaim stresses that it is absolutely forbidden to take action against any party without firsthand confirmation of the evidence or valid testimony in beis din.

To believe the litigant based on his word alone is to accept loshon hora; to punish the other party based on such loshon hora is an additional sin; to exact corporal punishment would be a grave transgression of a Torah prohibition (see Devarim 25:3).

Categories
Shmiras Haloshon

How to Determine Who Is the Villian

Categories
30 Seconds to Proper Speech Proper Speech

Harming A Student

Finally, a teacher must be careful not to cause his student undue harm. Halachah permits a teacher to strike a child for educational purposes, and embarrassment may also be justified, if it is for the student’s benefit. (The Talmud states that striking one’s older child is prohibited as it may incite him to hit back.) However, in today’s era of brazenness, corporal punishment even in early childhood often teaches violence rather than discipline, and must be carefully evaluated. Verbal abuse by a teacher can have a decidedly negative effect on his students and may undermine all efforts at educating the students regarding Shmiras Haloshon.

In any situation where embarrassment or physical punishment might result from the teacher relating the student’s problem to others, he may do so only if the consequences are necessary for the student’s growth and development. As mentioned above (Day 26), teachers must also bear in mind the long-term effects of relating or recording negative information about a student.

Categories
Family Lesson a Day

Support for the Report

SEFER CHOFETZ CHAIM — Hilchos Lashon Hara 7:10-12

There is a rare situation where one is permitted to believe lashon hara. This is the case of “divarim nicarim”, (lit. recognizable signs), where evidence proves that the lashon hara is true.

In Sefer Shmuel, we are told that Shaul HaMelech had a crippled grandson named Mefiboshes. After his kingdom was secure, Dovid HaMelech showed exceptional kindness to Mefiboshes, assuring him of his inheritance and inviting him to live in Jerusalem and eat at the royal table.

Later, when Dovid’s own son, Avshalom, rebelled against him and forced Dovid to flee Jerusalem, Mefiboshes’ servant, Tziva, claimed that Mefiboshes was disloyal to Dovid and was hoping that the struggle between Dovid and Avshalom would allow the throne to be returned to the family of Shaul.

In the end, Avshalom’s rebellion was quashed and Dovid returned to Jerusalem. At that time, Mefiboshes came before Dovid looking unkempt: “… he did not bathe his feet, he did not trim his mustache, and he did not launder his clothing …” He claimed loyalty to Dovid, saying that his unkempt appearance was a sign of his grief over Dovid’s (temporary) overthrow.

Now Dovid was not sure whom to believe. Was Mefiboshes telling the truth, or was Tziva correct that Mefiboshes was disloyal, and his unkempt appearance was in fact a sign that he was mourning Dovid’s return to the throne?

Dovid decided to test Mefiboshes. He told him that since he did not know whom to believe, Mefiboshes and Tziva would divide Mefiboshes’ field in half.

Mefiboshes failed the test, as he responded with sharp words indicating his displeasure over Dovid’s return. Dovid accepted Tziva’s report as fact and his pronouncement that the field would be divided was carried out.

From this incident, the Chofetz Chaim derives that clear-cut evidence, permits us to believe lashon hara as fact. The Chofetz Chaim notes the following conditions:

The evidence must be strong, relevant evidence which the listener personally witnessed (as was the case with Dovid).

Based on the evidence, the subject’s actions cannot be explained in a positive light. If his actions could be explained in a positive light and he is an average Jew or better, then, as always, there is a mitzvah to give him the benefit of the doubt.

The information is important to know l’to’eles, for an important constructive reason (such as, so that the listener will know to keep his distance from the person). If the information is pointless, negative information (“He is really not bright”; or, “His great-uncle once robbed a bank”), then just as it is forbidden to speak such lashon hara, so it is forbidden to believe it.

The listener cannot rely on the information to attack the person physically, or to cause him a financial loss without taking him to beis din. (The case of Dovid and Mefiboshes involved special circumstances.)

IN A NUTSHELL

In certain specific situations, we are permitted to believe lashon hara when strong, relevant evidence indicates that the report is true.

 -A project of  Mesorah Publications –

Categories
Daily Companion

Weighing the Evidence

In this segment, the Chofetz Chaim examines the concept of Devarim HaNikarim, recognizable signs, as it applies to the laws of loshon hora. From a Talmudic interpretation of a story in Scripture (Shabbos 56a) we learn that at times loshon hora may be accepted as fact when there is circumstantial proof which supports it.

The Chofetz Chaim addresses the possibility that we might take this to be a blanket allowance for believing negative information about someone whenever we feel that the situation points to his guilt.

The Chofetz Chaim notes that this principle applies only to cases of toeles, where there is a constructive purpose being served. An example would be where a father has strong basis to suspect that the bad reports concerning his son’s friend are true. While a parent is permitted to warn his child to avoid bad company without such evidence, he may do so with greater conviction when his suspicions are supported by strong evidence.

The Chofetz Chaim reminds us that this allowance, like the ones which preceded it, does not apply to common loshon hora where people pointlessly discuss misjudgments, mistakes or negative personality traits of others.

The Chofetz Chaim also tells us that one is guilty of listening to loshon hora merely by turning his attention to hear someone degrade a person for having faults which the listener knows personally to be true. Consider the following:

A particularly unpleasant person works in your office — someone who is never friendly and is always ready to instigate trouble. You have witnessed these traits personally dozens of times, suffered through his tirades, and now possess all the evidence you need to form your opinion of him. If you walk by a group standing at the water cooler and the topic of the day is this person’s awful behavior, the Chofetz Chaim warns: “Don’t bend your ear to listen!” The fact that you have evidence which confirms their loshon hora is meaningless. This is not a case of toeles; therefore, their words are forbidden, as is listening to them.

The Chofetz Chaim says that a Jew should have no interest in hearing his fellow man being degraded. Rather, he should live by the words of Rabbeinu Yonah: “The correct path is to conceal the sins [of others] and to praise a person for the good which can be found in him. It is the way of fools to seek out the blemishes and mistakes of others and to criticize them; they never speak others’ praises or find the good in them” (Sha’arei Teshuvah §217).

Categories
Daily Companion

Two Conditions

In the previous segment, the Chofetz Chaim introduced us to the concept of “Devarim Hanikarim”recognizable signs (i.e. circumstantial proof) as a basis for believing certain forms of loshon hora.

There are two major conditions which must be fulfilled before we can apply this principle:

• The evidence must be directly related to the loshon hora and it must be strong, not superficial.
• The listener must recognize firsthand the validity of the evidence.

Chofetz Chaim cautions that even if we have powerful, firsthand evidence which permits us to believe the loshon hora, we are prohibited from sharing this information with others without a constructive reason.

As mentioned above, the source for the rule of Devarim Hanikarim is a Talmudic interpretation of a story in Scripture. In that incident, King David accepted a report that Mefiboshes, the son of King Shaul, was upset over David’s return to the throne after a rebellion had been quelled. When David returned, Mefiboshes went to meet him looking wholly unkempt. His unkempt appearance gave the impression that he was not happy with David’s return. Nevertheless, David did not rely on this evidence until he personally heard a harsh statement from the mouth of Mefiboshes; only then did David accept as fact the report which he had heard.

From here, says the Chofetz Chaim, we learn that only Devarim Hanikarimmamash, definite recognizable signs, can be used as proof regarding loshon hora (see Shabbos 56a with Rashi and Maharsha).

Categories
Shmiras Haloshon

Don’t Leap Before You Look!

Categories
30 Seconds to Proper Speech Proper Speech

With No Alternative

If after giving a situation much thought, a teacher comes to the conclusion that a particular student has a behavioral or learning problem and feels that it will not be possible to deal with the problem without the involvement of the principal, his colleagues, or the student’s parents, then the teacher should speak to the necessary party without delay.

Condition 5 of constructive speech (see Day 50) is that the speaker’s intent be purely for constructive reasons and not out of anger or frustration. This could be extremely trying when the student in question is disruptive and frequently upsets the teacher.

Difficult as it is, teachers must not take students’ behavior personally. The disruptive student is, in most cases, not fighting the teacher; he is struggling with himself as he deals with the challenges of life.

Categories
Family Lesson a Day

Off the Cuff

SEFER CHOFETZ CHAIM — Hilchos Lashon Hara 7:9

Shimshy is one of the funniest people I know. Have you ever seen him on Purim? Last year, he came to the Purim seudah dressed up as a candy machine, and the whole night, chocolate bars were falling out of his shirt!

“You know, before every yom tov, he goes to cheer up the elderly nursing home residents — and boy, does he cheer them up! I’ve seen some of them with tears of laughter running down their cheeks.

“And he’s very imaginative. Once, in the middle of the year, he came to the office building where his father works dressed up in a suit and tie, walked up to the security guard — an old man who’s been at the job for the last 40 years — opened his wallet and flashed a fake badge. ‘I’m from the F.B.I.,’ he said, ‘and we’re investigating some strange happenings in the building. You may be taken in for questioning.’ The poor fellow was scared out of his wits!”

While the speaker may think Shimshy’s antics with the security guard were funny, they were not. To frighten and trick the security guard involves a number of sins, the most serious being chillul Hashem.

The speaker is definitely guilty of speaking lashon hara. The question is: May the listeners believe what he has said?

The question revolves around something the Gemara calls “mesiach l’fi tumo” a casual remark.

In certain rare situations, we would not accept a person’s testimony in beis din, but we would rely on a casual remark this person made. The reasoning is simple. Even if the person is not trustworthy enough that his testimony can be relied upon, we might be able to rely on something he said casually when he was not intending to testify.

Example: If Mr. X is not considered a trustworthy person, we would not rely on his statement, “I know for a fact that Mr. Z has died.”

However, if Mr. X is seen exclaiming, “Woe is me! That Mr. Z should be taken at the prime of his life — and in front of my eyes — how terrible!” we might rely on it and declare that Mr. Z is no longer among the living.

Now let us apply this to the laws of lashon hara. If someone would say, “I saw Shimshy play a practical joke on the security guard at his father’s place of work,” we would not be allowed to believe it. However, in our illustration, the information about Shimshy was said in a casual conversation in which the speaker intended to praise Shimshy. Are we permitted to believe this?

No, says the Chofetz Chaim. The sin of believing lashon hara is explicitly stated in the Torah, and therefore the leniency of a casual remark, would not apply.

Instead, we should tell ourselves that whatever was said about Shimshy and the security guard was either patently false or grossly exaggerated. Our esteem for him should be the same as it was before we heard this report.

IN A NUTSHELL

We are not permitted to believe lashon hara even when said as a casual remark.

 -A project of  Mesorah Publications –

Categories
Daily Companion

The Trustworthy Witness

In this segment, the Chofetz Chaim begins discussing three situations where seemingly there is reason to allow the listener to acceptloshon hora as fact. These situations are:
1. Where the speaker’s integrity is, to your mind, beyond reproach, to the point where his word alone is equivalent (in your eyes) to that of two men testifying in court.

2. Where the derogatory information is inferred from an innocent remark which was not spoken with the intent of conveying negative information.

3. Where there is strong evidence indicating that the derogatory information is true.

The Chofetz Chaim devotes the remainder of this segment to a discussion of the first of these situations. Earlier (Day 42), we discussed a case where a person witnessed an act of sin, but knew that the sinner would ignore his words of rebuke. In this case, if it is likely the person will repeat the offense, then the witness would be allowed to relate the information to the sinner’s rav or someone else who is in a position to offer rebuke. One of the three conditions which make this permissible is that the rav or parent knows the witness and trusts his word as he would the testimony of two witnesses.

Here, the Chofetz Chaim points out that for the witness to be permitted to relate what he has seen, it would have to have been an act which was an intentional violation of a well-known halachah. However, in a situation where the perpetrator may have acted out of ignorance or unwittingly, the witness would be required to give him the benefit of the doubt. He would not be allowed to report the incident in a derogatory way to the person’s rav; if he did report it, the rav would not be permitted to accept the witness’s interpretation. The same applies in any situation where it is not clear that the subject has intentionally violated a mitzvah.

For instance, a local charity is seeking a donation from a successful young businessman in the community. The young man refuses to contribute. While giving charity is certainly required by the Torah, refusing a particular request is not a violation of that law. Perhaps the young man has given his share elsewhere, or has less to give than others think. In this example, even if the fundraiser feels that the young man is being stingy, he is not allowed to approach the young man’s rav and ask that he rebuke his congregant for his stinginess.

Similarly, even when the speaker is a person whom the listener trusts implicitly, he would not be permitted to accept any sort of report which the speaker is forbidden to discuss; for example, that the subject lacks intelligence, that he has a shameful family history, etc.

The Chofetz Chaim states that in cases where the information does pertain to an obvious sin, the listener cannot accept the report (from someone whom he trusts like two witnesses) for the purpose of rebuking unless the speaker himself witnessed the incident. Furthermore, the listener, may not repeat the information to others unless there is a constructive purpose (and all 7 conditions are met — see Day 77). Obviously, the listener may not cause the perpetrator physical or monetary harm as a result of the report.
It is important to bear in mind that when one approaches a rav or parent to exercise their positive influence on someone, a potentially volatile situation has been created. This is especially true regarding parents; many parents resent hearing negative reports about their children and when they are approached with such reports their defense mechanisms shift into high gear. In such cases, extreme care and caution should be exercised so that the negative words which are spoken can achieve their intended purpose.

Categories
Shmiras Haloshon

Just the Facts Please!

Categories
30 Seconds to Proper Speech Proper Speech

Problem Students

The dedicated teacher often finds it necessary to discuss the progress and difficulties of students with parents, colleagues and principals. A lack of clear guidelines with regard to loshon hora(2) can create either a free-for-all atmosphere, where people talk about anyone with anyone, or, at the other extreme, a simplistic approach to Shmiras Haloshon(3) which could inhibit the teacher’s effectiveness as an educator.

Generally speaking, the area of chinuch (child education and upbringing) constitutes a constructive purpose which would permit relating negative information concerning a student. However, the specific conditions which permit speaking negatively for a constructive purpose must never be overlooked.

Verification of facts is crucial. For a teacher to play amateur psychologist and hastily diagnose the student as having some complex disability or disorder without pursuing the matter properly constitutes recklessness – and the consequences can be devastating. To communicate one’s evaluation under such circumstances would be hotzaas shem ra (slander). It is an unfortunate fact that certain problematic children have not succeeded only as a result of having been misunderstood by a teacher, whose labeling tainted the image of that student in the eyes of all his future teachers.

A teacher must make every effort to fully understand the behavior of each student; he must not be swift to condemn. It is essential that a student feel comfortable about expressing his true feelings to his teacher (in a respectable manner, of course). Conditions 1-4 of constructive speech (see Day 50) necessitate a good heart-to-heart talk with the student before reporting a problem (unless one suspects that serious danger may be imminent).

Categories
Family Lesson a Day

Like Two Witnesses

SEFER CHOFETZ CHAIM — Hilchos Lashon Hara 7:7-8

There are certain situations where it might be permissible to believe lashon hara about someone, even though he is not known as someone who often commits serious sins.

Mr. Jacobs has been a respected member of the shul for three decades. He is known to be exceptionally honest and forthright, and the rav sometimes discusses private matters with him.

The rav once commented, “If Mr. Jacobs informs me of something of which I was unaware, I consider it as reliable as if I heard it from two witnesses in court!”

One day, Mr. Jacobs is walking by McDonald’s when he sees Mr. Farloran, a member of their shul, sitting at a table eating a cheeseburger. Mr. Jacobs waits until Farloran leaves the store and approaches him. “Excuse me,” he says politely, “may I ask you a question?”

“Mind your own business. Mr. Nosybody,” the man snaps. “I know what you want to ask me; it’s none of your concern.”

In this case, says the Chofetz Chaim, Mr. Jacobs would be correct to inform the rav, for it is important that the rav be aware of this situation, even if he cannot approach Mr. Farloran about the matter. And since Mr. Jacobs is as trustworthy in the rav’s eyes as two valid witnesses — the rav is permitted to believe his report.

However, this halachah applies only if Mr. Jacobs witnessed this himself. He would not be permitted to relate it if he heard about it from someone else, and the rav would not be permitted to believe it if he did relate it.

Even when Mr. Jacobs did witness it and the rav is permitted to believe his report, the rav cannot repeat the report to others.

Let us examine another case involving our friend Mr. Jacobs:

Mr. Jacobs approaches the rav one day to discuss the upcoming bar mitzvah of Chaim Birnik. “It’s so wonderful to see how well this boy is doing in yeshivah,” he remarks. “I remember his father, Mendy Birnik, from when we were teenagers. No rebbi could handle him; he was usually out of class, and sometimes out of school. Baruch Hashem, he straightened out, and he and his wife are raising fine children.”

There is no reason why the well-meaning Mr. Jacobs had to volunteer this information to the rav. He has been guilty of speaking lashon hara. Though the rav considers Mr. Jacobs as trustworthy as two valid witnesses, he is not permitted to believe this report about Mr. Birnik’s past.

Ideally, the rav should have stopped Mr. Jacobs as soon as he said, “I remember Mr. Birnik from when we were teenagers.” At that point, the rav could have said, “One second, my friend. Please don’t tell me anything uncomplimentary about Mr. Birnik’s youth. It’s really not important for me to know this.”

As the Chofetz Chaim notes, if the rav realized where the conversation was heading and did not stop it, then aside from listening to lashon hara, he also transgressed “And before a blind person do not place a stumbling block”, which forbids a Jew to cause another Jew to sin. This is what the rav would transgress by allowing Mr. Jacobs to continue with a report that is clearly lashon hara.

IN A NUTSHELL

One is permitted to believe a negative report that he needed to know and which was related to him by someone whom he trusts like two valid witnesses.

 -A project of  Mesorah Publications –

Categories
30 Seconds to Proper Speech Proper Speech

Character Deficiencies

Helping one’s fellow to improve his character also falls within the realm of toeles, constructive purpose. If an acquaintance requires character refinement, then the mitzvah to reprove one’s fellow Jew requires one to bring the matter to that person’s attention with care and sensitivity. However, if one feels incapable of offering reproof and knows that others are also aware of this person’s character deficiencies, he is permitted to discuss the matter with them and seek their advice or involvement, if necessary. Though we have seen that it is lowly and forbidden to speak negatively of someone even with those who are already aware of the information, constructive speech is not at all lowly.

Should one find it necessary to consult with someone who is unaware of this person’s deficiencies for guidance in how to approach the person, he may do so, for this too constitutes constructive speech. However, if it is possible to discuss the issue without mentioning names, then this course must be followed.We have already seen (Day 53) that if one seeks the active involvement of someone who is unaware of the situation, that individual would have to investigate the matter personally and verify the facts before taking definitive action.

Categories
Family Lesson a Day

A Known Sinner

SEFER CHOFETZ CHAIM — Hilchos Lashon Hara 7:5-6

Rabbi Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld, the great Rav of Jerusalem in the early 1900s, was known for his deep love of all Jews, even those who were fiercely anti-religious and considered themselves his enemies.

Once, one of Rav Yosef Chaim’s sworn enemies became seriously ill and was taken to a hospital run by Christian missionaries. The rabbanim of Jerusalem had issued a ban on using this hospital. During his hospital stay, the patient became progressively worse until his life was in danger.

The family knew that only the expert physicians at the Orthodox Jewish Shaarei Zedek Hospital could save his life. But they also knew that the hospital would not want to admit a patient who had ignored the rabbanim’s ban against using the missionary hospital.

To whom did the family turn in their hour of need? Rav Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld, of whom the patient once said, “We will fight to the death against Rabbi Sonnenfeld and his cronies.”

Upon hearing of the patient’s predicament, Rav Yosef Chaim, who was then past 70, leaped to his feet, grabbed his hat and coat, and hurried outside into a driving rainstorm. Within minutes, he had arrived at Shaarei Zedek and succeeded in having the man admitted.

R’ Yosef Chaim felt a deep, unconditional ahavas Yisrael for every Jew. We should emulate him. When we see a Jew who was raised in an atmosphere ignorant of Torah, we should pity him and attempt to show him the beauty of Torah. If we see a Jew who was religious but has now strayed from the Torah path, we should pray for him and show him, if at all possible, that we truly care for him.

We have already learned that there are times when it is permissible to inform others of someone’s sins. In this segment, the Chofetz Chaim offers an example of a person who knows that a certain act is considered a very serious sin, and nevertheless intentionally commits this sin many times. His sinfulness is well known to all. It is permissible to warn others to keep their distance from him, and to mention other forms of his misbehavior of which others might be unaware. The purpose of this is so that others will not be influenced by him. While we are concerned for the sinner’s neshamah and pray for him, we need to be concerned for others as well.

Since his sinfulness is well known to all, one is also permitted to believe a report of his behavior that is not well known.

“Four years ago, when we were both in 10th grade, Baruch and I cut class three days in a row — and got away with it!”

We have learned that including ourselves in the report does not give us the right to speak lashon hara. The fact that the speaker proudly speaks of his own antics does not give him the right to say this about Baruch. And the listener cannot believe the report about Baruch, though there is nothing wrong with believing what the speaker said about himself.

IN A NUTSHELL

We are permitted to speak against a known sinner so that others will not be influenced by him.

We may not speak lashon hara about others even when we include ourselves.

 -A project of  Mesorah Publications –

Categories
Daily Companion

Split Personalities

The famed R’ Yisrael Salanter once said that the “eleventh commandment” is “Don’t be a fool,” which means that the Torah obligates us to use our intelligence and life experience to navigate our lives. So, when someone known to be dishonest attempts to swindle your life’s savings, you are under no obligation to judge him favorably and give him the benefit of the doubt.

The Chofetz Chaim tells us that if someone is a confirmedrasha (wicked person), meaning that he openly and consistently transgresses Torah prohibitions, then one is allowed to accept loshonhora about him. The exact guidelines for classifying someone as a rasha are complex and are beyond the scope of this work. However, one point which has been mentioned earlier bears repeating. Nowadays, most non-observant Jews are people who have never been introduced to the beauty and truth of Torah Judaism. Rambam likens such a person to a “tinok shenishba,” a child who was captured by gentiles and who grew up ignorant of his heritage. Such a person is surely no rasha; we should treat him with love and compassion and surely we should not speak badly of him.

The Chofetz Chaim then discusses the case of a person who recounts a story which reflects poorly on himself and on someone else as well. For example, you are at your twenty-fifth high school reunion and a former classmate is amusing everyone with a story about the time he and a friend — who could not attend the reunion — put maple syrup on the teacher’s chair. While the speaker may find the story funny, his friend might not want to be remembered for such things. And most people would not want their children to discover such stories about them.

The halachah prohibits the listeners from accepting the loshon hora about the second person even though the speaker is incriminating himself as well. At first glance, this halachah seems difficult to observe. How am I to take a story which I heard firsthand and split it into two, believing it only regarding the speaker? The key here is to see halachah as a reality. As the Chofetz Chaim states, I cannot believe the story as far as it concerns the second person, because a Jew has a chezkaskashrus, a presumed status of one who is faithful to Torah and mitzvos — including the Torah’s requirements regarding proper behavior. Therefore, I have no right to believe that the second person has acted improperly unless I know this information firsthand.

A story about the great Torah leader Rabbi Moshe Feinstein bears mentioning. Halachah prohibits a person from walking in front of someone who is praying Shemoneh Esrei. Once, R’ Moshe was on his way to an important meeting when he noticed someone near the doorway praying Shemoneh Esrei. He stopped in his tracks and would go no further. “There is a wall blocking my path,” R’ Moshe explained. The wall, of course, was the strength of the halachah which prohibited him from walking any further. By seeinghalachah as a powerful reality, following its requirements becomes relatively easy.

Categories
30 Seconds to Proper Speech Proper Speech

Avoiding Flattery

Even where it is permissible to speak negatively for a constructive purpose, one must avoid insincere flattery. It is forbidden to be critical of someone when he is not present, yet demonstrate approval of his behavior in his presence. If the concern is that the person’s feelings not be hurt, then the solution is to express respect and concern for him as a person, but clear disapproval of his behavior.

If one is certain that reproof will be ignored, and is therefore prepared to publicize the person’s behavior as an attempt to induce him to change his ways, one must nevertheless approach the sinner first, so as not to be suspected of insincerity.

In the above case, where it is clear that the person will not be moved by rebuke, one can remove the need for first speaking to him by dispelling any possible suspicions concerning one’s own sincerity. For example, if one speaks against the perpetrator in public (in the presence of three) rather than speaking to individual members of the community in private, it becomes clear to all that the speaker could not be attempting to gain favor with the perpetrator by showing acceptance of his behavior. Similarly, if the speaker is known to be zealous and outspoken and would not be suspected of flattery, he could resort to private discussion. Also, if it is clear to all that the perpetrator is a difficult personality, and publicly criticizing his behavior could be dangerous, then one may speak against him in private without fear of personal suspicion.

Categories
Family Lesson a Day

Many Voices

SEFER CHOFETZ CHAIM — Hilchos Lashon Hara 7:3-4

Consider the following scenario:

Speaker #1: “You have no idea what kind of tricks Devorah pulls behind the teacher’s back!”

Speaker #2: “Yes, I’ve seen some of her antics myself. If she ever gets caught, she’s finished!”

Speaker #3: “I once saw her put a spider on the teacher’s chair as class was about to begin!”

It seems obvious that Devorah is quite a trouble­maker.

The halachah, however, takes a different approach. We are not permitted to believe any of the above statements.

The fact that three people seem to agree on Devorah’s misbehavior does not make it permissible to believe them. Each one is guilty of speaking lashon hara, and therefore her words cannot be accepted.

The Chofetz Chaim makes an interesting point. Speaking lashon hara is a terrible sin. Someone who intentionally commits such a sin can certainly be suspected of exaggerating or even lying. On the other hand, an average Jew has a chezkas kashrus, meaning that we assume him to be innocent until proven guilty. Why, then, should I assume that the words of these sinners are true? Wouldn’t it make more sense to assume that those who have spoken lashon hara are misrepresenting the facts and that Devorah, who until now had a chezkas kashrus, is innocent?

What if three people agree on the following?

“Pinchas has acted recklessly with other people’s money. It is foolhardy to do business with him.”

In this case, it is correct to consider the possibility that the report might be true and to take the necessary precautions. However, we are not allowed to believe the report, even though three people claim that it is true, and even though if it is true, they are correct in relating it.

One may wonder: Why are we not permitted to believe a report delivered by two or more people? We know that according to Torah law, two witnesses are the minimum needed to testify in beis din. We also know that the testimony of two witnesses is as powerful as that of 100. So, if two Jews state that they know firsthand about Pinchas’ reckless use of other people’s money, why can’t I believe them?

The Chofetz Chaim explains that if the two would offer their testimony in beis din, we would be permitted to believe them. Witnesses know that testifying in beis din is a very serious matter. If they are caught lying, they are labeled false witnesses and would be disqualified from testifying in the future. Therefore, when they do testify, we assume that their words are true until proven otherwise.

Our case, however, is where the testimony is being offered outside of beis din. Here, if the speakers are caught lying they would be called those who spread slander a serious matter, but not as serious as being labeled false witnesses by a Jewish court. Therefore, we are permitted to consider the possibility that their words are true and act accordingly to protect ourselves, but we are not permitted to believe their words as fact.

We are also not permitted to believe rumors or reports about Jews in the media, no matter how many news outlets report the information. However, we are permitted to inquire about the report and protect our­selves in case it might be true.

IN A NUTSHELL

Even when lashon hara is related by three or more people, we are not permitted to believe it as fact.

 -A project of  Mesorah Publications –

Categories
Daily Companion

Double Trouble

The Chofetz Chaim offers another reason why we should not believe loshon hora which is said in our presence.

When a person speaks loshon hora, he transgresses the negative commandment of “You should not go as a peddler of gossip” (Vayikra19:16), thereby putting himself in the category of a rasha (evil person). As a rasha his words certainly have no credibility, and we may suspect him of lying, exaggerating, and distorting the truth. Furthermore, this wicked individual is telling us negative information about someone who is assumed to be an upstanding, observant Jew! Certainly we should not accept his wicked words as fact.

If we hear the same negative information from two or more people, we may be more inclined to believe it. This is incorrect, says the Chofetz Chaim, because when wicked people speak wicked words, numbers are meaningless. Even if a dozen people are offering the same derogatory information, it should not be accepted.

The Chofetz Chaim adds that this halachah (law) applies even when the two speakers are not deemed reshaim (wicked people). For example, suppose two people approach Levi in the street and inform him that Yehuda is planning to ruin his business. If they are telling the truth, then they are actually doing a mitzvah by warning Levi. Nevertheless, Levi can only protect himself on the chance that the report is true; he cannot accept it as fact.

This is because the testimony of two people has validity only in beis din (rabbinical court). When two people report negative information about someone outside of beis din, they are not restrained by the possibility of being branded as false witnesses, for there can be no such designation outside of beis din. Therefore, their report cannot be accepted as fact.

If a rumor circulates in a city that a Jew committed a crime, one is not allowed to believe it. This applies also to reports in newspapers or other media sources. In this case, too, if the information is relevant for constructive purposes, one should proceed with appropriate caution.

However, there are instances in which one may believe negative reports. When an abundance of reports regarding a certain person circulate over a period of time, telling of various sinful acts which he committed, to the point where he is no longer viewed as an observant Jew, then it would be permissible to believe the reports. As the Chofetz Chaim puts it, we are not required to think that the community has made a mistake again and again regarding the same individual.

Categories
Shmiras Haloshon

Double Trouble

Categories
30 Seconds to Proper Speech Proper Speech

Loshon Hora and the Non-Observant

Based on the rules we have just studied, the rules of loshon hora vis-a-vis the totally non-observant Jew become clear.

(1) The average non-observant Jew today has been deprived of a meaningful Jewish education. Whether or not he has been exposed to Orthodox Jewish life, society has prevented him from taking Torah seriously. Rambam compares such a person to a tinok shenishbah, a kidnapped Jewish child whose kidnappers reared him with non-Torah ideals, and whose transgressions are committed out of ignorance. Such a person may be in the category of both amecha, your people and amiso, hisfellow. It is our obligation to educate him with love, care, and sensitivity and it is strictly forbidden to speak loshon hora against him.

(2) A non-observant Jew who did receive a meaningful Jewish education, has been taught Torah values and knows that what he is doing is wrong, but claims that observance is too difficult, is a rebel due totemptation. He is considered part of amecha, your people, which means that loshon hora may be spoken of him only if it is for a constructive purpose. However, he is not considered amisecha, your fellow, and consequently the prohibition of onaas devarim, causing hurt through the spoken word (Vayikra 25:17), will not apply in his case. Social pressure may be used to encourage observance even if he will suffer embarrassment in the process, provided that all the conditions of constructive speech are met. Non-constructive speech that is either derogatory or harmful would constitute loshon hora.

(3) The classic apikores (heretic) who is knowledgeable but rebels is considered neither your brother nor a part of your people. If there exists such a person today, one may speak abouthim without any preconditions.

Categories
Family Lesson a Day

Compelling Situations

SEFER CHOFETZ CHAIM — Hilchos Lashon Hara 7:1-2

The annual shul dinner is in progress. The key­note speaker, a renowned community leader, is speaking about the importance of keeping the neighborhood clean and neat. “It is disgraceful,” he thunders, “when the schools in which we educate our children are sloppy and disorganized. Yeshivah Emes L’Amito is a prime example of this … ”

Mr. Gold turns to his friend Mr. Greenberg, and whispers, “I’m not familiar with that yeshivah — are you?” “No,” Mr. Greenberg replies, “but this fellow seems to know what he is talking about. I guess that place is a mess. I certainly won’t be sending my sons to that yeshivah.”

Of course, the speaker was guilty of speaking lashon hara. Such a statement about a yeshivah reflects badly upon the school administration, the rebbeim and teachers, and possibly the students as well.

Mr. Gold and Mr. Greenberg were not permitted to believe this lashon hara. The fact that the speaker was not afraid to make this statement in front of hundreds of people does not prove that it is true.

However, Mr. Greenberg, who had been considering that yeshivah for his son, is permitted to suspect that the statement might possibly be true. The best option would be for him to visit the yeshivah himself and see firsthand whether or not it is “sloppy and disorganized.”

The boys are quite upset. The gym door is jammed and cannot be opened with a key. They will have to spend their recess in the classroom.

Josh announces to everyone, “I know why it’s jammed. Every time the door is locked, Tzvi tries to force it open. Right, Tzvi? … You see, he’s not answering, because he knows it’s true!”

It seems quite obvious that Josh is right. After all, if Tzvi is not the culprit, why is he remaining silent?

The Chofetz Chaim states:

There is no license to accept lashon hara, even if the speaker makes his statements in the person’s presence, since we did not hear an admission from him … and certainly this is the halachah where the person is not present and the speaker says, “I would say this even if he were here” — it is forbidden to believe him because of this. Tragically, people transgress this halachah often.

Even if he is silent as the words of shame are being said in his presence, this is not proof that the statement is true. This is the halachah even if his nature is not to remain silent when hearing words that are not pleasing to him, and this time he remained silent. For it could be that this time he overcame his nature, and decided not to respond so that he would not be drawn into a dispute; or perhaps he realized that the listeners would more likely believe the speaker’s report rather than his denial. For this is the wicked way of people: they believe anything said in the person’s presence; even if he denies it 100 times, still they will not believe him.

The golden rule is: Don’t believe lashon hara. At times, this may be a very difficult test, but Jews also live by another rule. Hashem does not present us with a test that we cannot handle. The mitzvah of shemiras halashon is within everyone’s power to keep; if we will only make the proper effort, Hashem will help us to succeed.

IN A NUTSHELL
Do not believe lashon hara, even when it is said in front of a large crowd or in the presence of the subject.

 -A project of  Mesorah Publications –

Categories
Daily Companion

Jumping to Conclusions

We have learned that if someone says, “This isn’t loshon hora. I would say it right in front of him!” the Torah still classifies the statement as loshon hora and we are not permitted to believe it.

Now the Chofetz Chaim takes the case one step further. What if the speaker actually does say the loshon hora in front of the other person? For example, Reuven says in Shimon’s presence, “I saw with my own eyes how Shimon cheated on yesterday’s exam.” Shimon responds with silence. Can we interpret his silence as admission of guilt?

The Chofetz Chaim says that we cannot surmise that the information is true, because there can be a host of reasons why Shimon would stay quiet in such a situation, even if the information were not true. For example, Shimon might reason that people are more likely to believe Reuven’s words which were said about him in his presence, than to believe his denial. Or, he might be silent simply because he wants to avoid conflict.

The Chofetz Chaim suggests that the person may have chosen to be counted among the “those who suffer insult.” He is alluding to an important Talmudic teaching (Shabbos 88b):

“Those who suffer insult but do not insult (in response), who hear their disgrace but do not reply, who perform (God’s will) out of love and are happy in suffering, regarding them the verse states ‘But they who love Him (God) shall be as the sun going forth in its might’ ” (Shoftim 5:31). As the commentators explain, this means that those who bear insult in silence will not be diminished because of this1, while their antagonists will be humbled in the end.

The Torah demands that we never jump to conclusions, even when matters seem as clear as day. The case of one who is silent in the face of insult is an excellent illustration of this truth.

1. As the Talmud relates (Chullin 60b), at the time of Creation the moon was as large as the sun but was diminished when it complained that it was not fitting for two luminaries to reign together. The sun, which did not respond to the moon’s complaint, remained unchanged.

Categories
Shmiras Haloshon

Jumping to Conclusions

Categories
30 Seconds to Proper Speech Proper Speech

Public Announcements

Traditionally, Jewish communities have used social pressure in dealing with the publicly observant whose private behavior includes blatant violation of basic halachah.

If all else fails, it is permissible to publicize the fact that an otherwise observant Jew is guilty of immorality on a regular basis, if the disclosure will prompt him to repent.

Similarly, rabbinical courts have the authority to post signs informing the public of someone’s refusal (siruv) to comply with a court ruling. Social pressure is often the only means through which rabbinical courts can enforce their decisions.

Categories
Family Lesson a Day

A Tragic Episode

SEFER CHOFETZ CHAIM — Hilchos Lashon Hara 6:11-12

R’ Yosef Colon (1410-1480), known as Maharik, writes of a tragic episode that happened in his time. A woman spread a rumor in a certain town that an elderly Jewish townsman had committed a terrible sin. Many of the townspeople believed the woman and they prevailed upon the leaders of the community to treat the man as a sinner. From then on, he was never called to the Torah in that town and was an object of scorn and disgrace.

Maharik wrote:

Whoever embarrassed this man should beg Hashem for mercy for himself, for he takes a carefree attitude towards the honor of the descendants of Avraham, Yitzchak, and Yaakov. Without a doubt, people who react this way (to rumors) are despicable in Hashem’s eyes and their punishment will be severe. … One who embarrasses his fellow Jew in public forfeits his share in the World to Come. … A person should investigate such a rumor thoroughly before acting upon it. One who does not is taking his own life in his hands.

The Chofetz Chaim points out that the testimony of a single witness in beis din can force someone to swear that he is telling the truth; however, it does not permit anyone to believe the testimony as fact.

The Chofetz Chaim bemoans an all-too-common occurrence:

Binny the Beggar has been collecting tzedakah for himself for years. One day, a respected member of the community announces: “You know what I heard the other day? Binny’s a phony — he has thousands of dollars stashed away in the bank, enough to live on for the next 60 years! Well, he’s not getting any money out of me anymore!”

People who listen to this announcement are quick to believe it. From that day on, when Binny approaches them with his hand outstretched, they offer him an icy stare, but no money.

These people, says the Chofetz Chaim, are guilty of believing lashon hara. They would be permitted to investigate the report to determine whether or not there is any truth to it. However, until they have conclusive proof that Binny is a faker, they are obligated to assume that he is an honest person and truly is poor. And they must give him the same amount of tzedakah as before.

If someone believed lashon hara and has not repeated it to anyone and seeks to engage in teshuvah, the process is not complicated. He must do his best to uproot the report from his mind; he must regret his sin and resolve to do his best not to repeat it in the future; and he must confess to Hashem for having sinned.

Uncomplicated, yes; easy, no. Once we believe something negative about someone, it is not easy to uproot it and convince ourselves that it is not true. Nevertheless, we must try our best if we truly seek to dis­tance ourselves from the terrible sin of lashon hara.

IN A NUTSHELL

Until a negative report is proven true, we must treat the subject with the same respect and kindness as before.

One who has believed lashon hara must engage in the standard process of teshuvah.

 -A project of  Mesorah Publications –

Categories
Daily Companion

A Proper Mindset

The Chofetz Chaim begins this segment by stressing that many people react incorrectly in cases of negative reports, where the listener needs to reckon with the report and protect himself. While the rules of such cases are complex, the Chofetz Chaim reiterates the basic rule: The Torah allows us only to protect ourselves on the possibility that the information is accurate. Never does the Torah give a person the right to use such information to act against the subject or to cause him a monetary loss. And because the information cannot be accepted as fact (without personal verification), it is absolutely forbidden to harbor any hatred toward that person. Finally, one cannot use the report as an excuse to cancel any obligations toward that person.

The Chofetz Chaim illustrates this last point: A person with an established reputation of being poor is circulating in shul (synagogue) collecting tzedakah (charity) for himself. Your neighbor turns to you and says, “This fellow’s a faker; I hear that he makes more money than we do.” The Chofetz Chaim says that if you decide not to give this man money (without investigation), or to give him less than you normally would, then you are in the category of one who believes loshon hora. For until the man is proven to be a fraud, you have to accord him his original status — that of a poor, upstanding Jew — and to treat him as such.

This is just one small example, says the Chofetz Chaim, of the consequences of accepting loshonhora.

The Chofetz Chaim also deals with a situation where the listener has transgressed by accepting the loshon hora as fact. Now, he regrets his sin. What should he do to rectify it?

The Chofetz Chaim offers a three-point plan:

1. He should strengthen himself and uproot this information from his mind to the point where he no longer believes it.

2. He should accept upon himself to be careful in the future not to accept loshon hora.

3. He should confess his sin (viduy) before Hashem.

The last two of these steps are common to the teshuvah process for any sin. But the requirement that we actually uproot information which we already believe to be true — this seems difficult to navigate.

Rabbi Avraham Pam, z”l, explained how it can be done. He says we must immerse our hearts inthe mitzvah of judging people favorably. If youheard that the subject caused hurt to your friend,tell yourself, “I’m sure it didn’t happen exactly as itwas reported.” Or, “Perhaps he is going throughsome personal difficulties. Who knows what I would do in thesame situation?” Keep your mind focused like a laser beam onthese favorable interpretations and review them again and again.If you flood your thoughts with favorable judgments, you will beamazed to find a gradual change in your thinking take place, asanger gives way to love for your fellow Jew.

Categories
Shmiras Haloshon

A Proper Mindset

Categories
30 Seconds to Proper Speech Proper Speech

Social Pressure

A mumor l’tayovon (lit., rebel due to temptation) is someone who regularly submits to temptation in violating a specific mitzvah. While the prohibition against gossip mongering does apply with regard to speaking about him (as he is not a heretic), his situation differs drastically from one who occasionally transgresses a given mitzvah but basically is committed to its observance.

As we have learned, the primary prohibition against speaking loshon hora is lo saylaych rachil b’amecha, Do not go as a gossipmonger among your people (Vayikra 19:16). One who embarrasses his fellow Jew transgresses the prohibition lo sonu ish es amiso, A man shall not aggrieve his fellow (Vayikra 25:17).Our Sages interpret the term amecha, your people, in the first prohibition as excluding only a mumor l’hachis, (lit., rebel whose intent is to spite), one whose lack of regard for a given prohibition causes him to regularly transgress it. However, the term, amiso, his fellow, in the second prohibition, excludes even the mumor l’tayovon. Thus, it is forbidden to speak loshon hora about a mumor l’tayovon but it is permissible to exert social pressure on him in order to induce him to mend his sinful way.

It is permissible to publicize that a Jew regularly violates a particular halachah if it is clear that he is aware of the halachah and has chosen to ignore it, and it stands to reason that publicizing his behavior will induce him to change. This applies even if he transgresses the law out of temptation. However, one must be certain that all the conditions of toeles, constructive speech, including purity of intent and lack on an alternative, apply.

Categories
Family Lesson a Day

The Falsehood of Lashon Hara

SEFER CHOFETZ CHAIM — Hilchos Lashon Hara 6:9-10

Sefer Yad Ketanah analyzes the verse that prohibits us from believing lashon hara: “Do not accept a false report.” We have learned that lashon hara is forbidden even if it is true. And, in the Chofetz Chaim’s words, “Whatever we are not permitted to speak, we are not permitted to believe.” Why, then, does the Torah use the term “false report”?

Yad Ketanah explains: “Any statement that is disgusting and repulsive is considered false, even if in reality its facts are true. This is because such statements lack substance; no good is found in them, only evil.”

The Chofetz Chaim adds a beautiful thought:

Michoel is a fine, Torah-observant Jew. He is respected and loved by all. One day, someone approaches you and says, “You know, I just found out about Michoel’s dark past. He was arrested twice for shoplifting — before he mended his ways.”

Of course, the listener is not permitted to believe this. The Chofetz Chaim explains that even if the facts about Michoel’s past are true, the statement is inherently false.

What is the speaker hoping to accomplish by spreading his evil report? Obviously, it bothers him that people hold Michoel in high esteem. The speaker is hoping that by telling everyone about Michoel’s past, people will think less of him.

Says the Chofetz Chaim, this is false! The report, even if it is absolute truth, is not a reason to think less of Michoel. He has done teshuvah, he has mended his ways, and asked Hashem to forgive him for the sins of his past. Those sins are not a reason to think less of him now.

The Chofetz Chaim cites the words of Rambam regarding a sinner who has completed the process of teshuvah:

Yesterday, he was separated from Hashem, G-d of Israel … but today, he is attached to the Shechinah.

Because, as we have said, whatever cannot be spoken cannot be accepted as truth, we also cannot believe reports that someone is “not that bright,” “a weakling,” or “failing in business.” As we have learned, all such statements could cause damage to a person’s future, and therefore are lashon hara.

We have learned that one is allowed to listen to [what would nor­mally be considered] lashon hara to protect himself from possible physi­cal or financial harm. The Chofetz Chaim stresses that in the listener’s mind, it should not be a “50-50 possibility” that the information is true. Rather, he should tell himself that the information is probably not true, but he is taking the necessary steps to protect himself on the slight chance that it is true.

Therefore, the listener is not permitted to think less of the subject of the report. He should continue to view him as a fine Jew and should assist him with his needs in the same way that he would have before hearing the report.

IN A NUTSHELL

Derogatory information about others is inherently false.

We may not accept as fact any form of lashon hara; when we need to listen to lashon hara l’to’eles, we may act on the slight possibility that the report is true.

 -A project of  Mesorah Publications –

Categories
Shmiras Haloshon

Action Without Judgment

Categories
30 Seconds to Proper Speech Proper Speech

The Habitual Sinner

In the case of a habitual sinner who ignores a particular commandment altogether, one is to assume that even a questionable act is, in fact, a transgression of that commandment. “Judge your fellow favorably” demands fairness, not naiveté.

Having concluded that the person did transgress, one must then seek to understand why he frequently commits this sin. It may be due to ignorance – he may be totally unaware that the act is forbidden, or he might not realize the severity of the prohibition. Should this be the case, one must find some way of enlightening the person without hurting his feelings. Discussing his behavior with others constitutes speaking loshon hora. (This situation is common among those who were raised in communities where there is widespread violation of certain laws. In such instances, people mistakenly view those who observe these laws as machmirim, individuals who are stringent beyond the letter of the law.)

Categories
Family Lesson a Day

Heard Outside the Courtroom

SEFER CHOFETZ CHAIM — Hilchos Lashon Hara 6:7-8

Levi and Hanoch agreed to end their business partnership and have a beis din decide how their assets should be divided. On the day beis din issued its decision, Hanoch left very upset. As he walked down the street, he met his good friend Moshe, who was well aware of the court case. Hanoch showed his friend the written p’sak (ruling) and exclaimed, “Did you ever hear of something more ridiculous in your entire life? They gave virtually everything of value to Levi! Those rabbanim don’t know what they’re doing!”

Moshe shook his head in disbelief as he handed the p’sak back to his friend. “I can’t believe what I just read. You’re right. Those rabbanim really blew it! It’s a shame you didn’t bring the case before a more qualified beis din. Any intelligent person can see that you were not given a fair deal.”

If you were to ask Moshe whether or not any of his comments were in the category of forbidden speech, he might very well respond incredulously, “Forbidden speech? What are you talking about? I just stated my opinion about a p’sak — what could be wrong with that?”

The Chofetz Chaim teaches us that Moshe is guilty of accepting lashon hara and of not giving the judges the benefit of the doubt. The judges are, of course, talmidei chachamim. We are required to give a talmid chacham the benefit of the doubt even when it appears more likely that he has acted incorrectly. In our case, it is foolish for Moshe to side with Hanoch based on the written p’sak. Moshe was not in court and did not hear the arguments and counter-arguments. It is very possible that had he been present in beis din and witnessed certain points or questions raised by the dayanim (judges), he would realize that the p’sak is absolutely correct.

Aside from the sins we have mentioned, when people speak disrespectfully of a beis din and its rulings, they disgrace the Torah itself and they influence others to ignore, or even ridicule, the words of talmidei chachamim. This itself is a terrible sin.

There are other situations where not giving someone the benefit of the doubt will lead to kabbalas lashon hara — even where the listener knows the facts to be true:

Chayah called in sick and was not at work for two days. On the second day of her absence, two of her co-workers saw her eating lunch with friends in a restaurant. One remarked, “Look at that! I guess she couldn’t be that sick if she is able to go out and party!” The other responded, “I guess some people will resort to lying to take a couple of days off.”

In this example, the first co-worker is guilty of speaking lashon hara. The second is also guilty of accepting lashon hara. Both are guilty of not giving Chayah the benefit of the doubt. It is quite possible that Chayah did not feel well enough to work, but she was well enough to go out for lunch with some friends. Perhaps her fever broke a couple of hours earlier and then she started to feel better. Or, it may be that she really did not want to go out for lunch, but she felt that she could not refuse her friends’ request to join them at the restaurant.

The mitzvah of shemiras halashon and of giving others the benefit of the doubt is very much intertwined.

IN A NUTSHELL

Not giving others the benefit of the doubt often leads to accepting lashon hara and the disgrace of talmidei chachamim.

 -A project of  Mesorah Publications –

Categories
Daily Companion

Think Positive

In the course of a day, the average person hears hundreds of pieces of information. As each one is digested, we are left to decide whether or not we choose to accept it as fact. And when it comes to loshon hora, many people find themselves inclined to believe what they hear.

In this segment, the Chofetz Chaim discusses a case where the listener knows firsthand that the facts which the speaker is relating are all true. The problem is that the speaker has chosen to interpret these facts in a negative way. Here the listener is obligated to fulfill the mitzvah of “Judge your fellow with righteousness” (Vayikra 19:15), and to interpret the facts in a positive light. If he fails to do so, then he has transgressed the mitzvahto judge others favorably, in addition to being guilty of accepting loshon hora.

The Chofetz Chaim offers the following example:

Reuven is walking down the street when he meets Shimon emerging from the local beis din (rabbinical court). Shimon is terribly agitated; he has just lost a din Torah (court case) involving a monetary dispute with Levi. Shimon waves thepsakdin (court ruling) at Reuven. “Did you ever hear something so ridiculous in all your life?” he shouts. “It was obvious that I deserved to win! These dayanim (judges) don’t know what they’re doing! Any other beis din would have seen things my way!”

If Reuven agrees with Shimon, he is guilty of not judging favorably and of accepting loshon hora. In this case, his sins are compounded by the fact that we are dealing with dayanim, who are accomplished Torah scholars.

What Reuven should do is try to convince Shimon that the dayanim have surely done their best to judge fairly and honestly. Furthermore, if in truth Shimon is correct and Levi has cheated him, then he should rest assured that Hashem has infinite methods at His disposal to make up the loss to him.

And what should Reuven tell himself if it appears to him that Shimon is right and the judges have erred? He should realize that without having been present at the din Torah, he cannot possibly know the full story. As such, it should not be too difficult for him to give the dayanim the benefit of the doubt.

Categories
Shmiras Haloshon

Think Positive

Categories
30 Seconds to Proper Speech Proper Speech

The Occasional Sinner

If a person whose actions may have involved a given transgression is known to commit that particular sin at least occasionally, then the commandment, “Judge your fellow favorably,” does not require that one seek a positive explanation for what he did. However, it is meritorious to give the person the benefit of the doubt and assume that this time he did not sin. Reproof would not be necessary.

If it is absolutely clear that the person did commit a sin, then the mitzvah to reprove does apply and one should, in a respectful and caring manner, help the person to overcome his evil inclination by offering reproof.

There are times when it would be more effective for someone else, such as a close friend or rav, to reprove the individual. Theoretically, it should be permissible for the one who witnessed the transgression to inform the friend or rav of it and ask that he handle the situation. However, we have learned that one may not act on hearsay, which would mean that one cannot possibly offer reproof unless he personally witnessed the transgression. Consequently, it would be one’s responsibility to find an effective means of reproving himself, or to ask the rav to either personally investigate the situation or tactfully discuss the matter with that individual without making accusations.

Categories
Family Lesson a Day

War for the Sake of Hashem

SEFER CHOFETZ CHAIM — Hilchos Lashon Hara 6:5-6

In this segment, the Chofetz Chaim discusses a situ­ation where one finds himself among people who are in the midst of speaking lashon hara. What should one do at this moment?

The language used by the Chofetz Chaim here is so powerful and incredible that we will translate, rather than adapt, his words. Bear in mind that the Chofetz Chaim was exceedingly careful with his every word. Nothing is exaggerated; everything is precise.

Says the Chofetz Chaim:

If the person is able to leave this gathering or to place his fingers in his ears, it is a great mitzvah to do so, as is stated in Masechta Kesubos. However, if it is impossible for him to leave the gathering, and he feels that it is too difficult to place his fingers in his ears because they will laugh at him, then he should gather his energy and remain steadfast during this time of distress, and wage a war for the sake of Hashem against his yetzer hara, so that he should not transgress the Torah prohibition against accepting lashon hara.

For this, he needs to be very careful with three things …

1. He must decide in his mind that he absolutely will not believe the disparaging words that are being said about others.

2. It should not please him to hear these forbid­den accounts.

3. He should be steadfast in not showing the speakers any sort of facial expression or movement that might indicate that he agrees with what they are saying. Rather, he should sit stony-faced. It would be even better for him to show an angry face so that they will realize that he does not endorse their foolish words.

In a situation where one could easily have left the group and did not, or where he joined a group knowing that a sinful conversation was in progress, or where he joined knowing that these people are prone to speaking lashon hara, he is as guilty as they are, for our Sages have instructed us to distance ourselves from forbidden talk. If someone joins such a group with the intention of listening to their evil talk, then certainly, says the Chofetz Chaim “his sin is too great to bear.”

The Chofetz Chaim concludes by quoting the ethical will of the Tanna R’ Eliezer ben Hyrkanos to his son:

My son, do not sit among groups who speak evil of others, for when these words ascend Above they are recorded in a book. Those who are present are inscribed [in that book] as a wicked group, baalei lashon hara.

Someone posed the following question to Rabbi Avraham Pam: “Every afternoon after completing my day’s work, I stand at a bus stop waiting for a bus to take me home. Very often, a certain person I know passes by in his car on his way home from work and offers me a ride. Many times during these rides, this man launches into a tirade about various people. Am I permitted to accept such a ride?”

Rav Pam responded that he should not accept a ride from this person, for by doing so, he would be entering into a nisayon (test) of possibly listening to and accepting lashon hara. Each day in Birchos HaShachar, said Rav Pam, we pray that we should not be faced with spiritual tests. How, then, can we knowingly enter a situation where we might be tested?

ְִִֵֹ

IN A NUTSHELL

When we hear lashon hara against our will, we must make sure not to believe it, and we should give every indication that we are unhappy about it.

 -A project of  Mesorah Publications –

Categories
Daily Companion

Standing Firm

The Chofetz Chaim introduces us to a situation with which we are all familiar: You are sitting at someone’s Shabbos table or at a wedding, and several people start speaking loshon hora. What do you do? As we have just learned, listening to loshon hora is forbidden; how, then, can you avoid transgression? The Chofetz Chaim discusses your options.

1. You can rebuke the gossipers (making sure, of course, to do it in a respectful way). You can remind them that this is a Torah prohibition, halachically equivalent to munching on shrimp or bacon.

2. If you know that they will not listen to rebuke, then “it is a great mitzvah,” writes the Chofetz Chaim, to get up and leave table.

3. If you find this impossible, then you should prepare yourself to stand firm so that you will not be guilty of any sin. Make sure to fulfill the following requirements:

a. Decide firmly in your mind that you will refuse to believe any loshon hora.

b. Make sure that your facial expression does not convey any hint of approval of what is being said. At the very least, you should sit stone-faced; if possible, your expression should convey strong disapproval.

The above applies if one is innocently sitting at one’s place when the loshon hora conversation begins. However, if someone strolls through an area where he overhears such a conversation and stops to listen, or if he passes by a group known to be gossipers and stops to listen to their conversation, then, says the Chofetz Chaim, he is considered a willful sinner, even if he takes no part in the conversation and does not approve of it.

The Chofetz Chaim continues that if one associates with such a group with the intention of hearing what they have to say, then he will be inscribed in Heaven as a baal loshon hora (a habitual speaker of loshon hora) and “his sin is too great to bear.”

In a famous incident, the Chofetz Chaim was traveling when he found himself in the company of a group of traders who were deeply engrossed in conversation. The Chofetz Chaim approached them and said, “And what, may I ask, are we talking about? If it’s horses count me in, but if it’s people count me out!” How did he do it?

How did the Chofetz Chaim have the courage to approach mere strangers and tell them, “If it’s people [you’re talking about], count me out”? The answer is that the Chofetz Chaim understood precisely what was at stake. He knew that our Sages teach that one will be inscribed in Heaven as a baal loshon hora for willfully joining a group of gossipers. To the Chofetz Chaim, confronting these men with his question was a small sacrifice, when the stakes were so very high.

Categories
Shmiras Haloshon

3 Options for Dealing with Negative Talk

Categories
Family Lesson a Day

Constructive Listening

SEFER CHOFETZ CHAIM — Hilchos Lashon Hara 6:3-4

Yisrael is hurrying down the street towards his friend Rafi. “Rafi,” he exclaims, “I’m sure you know the Stein fellow who lives around the corner from us — the one who always seems to be in an

angry mood. You’ve got to hear what he’s up to!”

It certainly appears as if Yisrael is about to relate lashon hara about Mr. Stein. We have learned that it is forbidden to intentionally listen to lashon hara even if we do not intend to believe it. So it would seem that Rafi would have to tell Yisrael that he does not want to hear this bit of information.

On the other hand, the information may be important for Rafi to know; either to protect himself from harm, or so that he can help to defuse a potentially explosive situation.

What should Rafi do? He should say the following:

“Yisrael, before you say another word, please tell me the truth. Is it really important for me to know what Mr. Stein did? If not, I do not want to hear anything about it.”

If is apparent from Yisrael’s response that it is important for Rafi to know what happened, he would be permitted to listen to the report, provided that he does not believe it as fact. If, on the other hand, Yisrael is merely eager to share some “juicy information,” or wants to spread negative information about Mr. Stein because he dislikes him, it would be forbidden to listen.

The Chofetz Chaim offers some examples in which the information will not save Rafi from harm, but nevertheless, he is permitted to listen to it:

Rafi has a feeling that Mr. Stein is not as guilty as Yisrael thinks he is. By listening to the account of what supposedly happened, Rafi will be able to show Yisrael and others who are present that Mr. Stein is not such a bad fellow after all.

Yisrael comes towards Rafi with a somewhat different outburst: “Yisrael, you know that Stein fellow from around the corner? You know what he just did to me? Just wait until I get even with him!”

In this case, Rafi may feel that he will be able to calm Yisrael and defuse the situation. By doing this, says the Chofetz Chaim, Rafi will be “increasing peace among the Jewish people.” This is in fact a mitzvah and warrants Rafi’s listening to what happened.

The Chofetz Chaim cautions, however, that Rafi should be extremely careful not to believe the report as fact “so that he will not be trapped in the net of kabbalas lashon hara.”

Sometimes we fall into this “net” quite innocently.

Tzippy is sitting at a wedding enjoying the company when someone at her table tells a very unflattering story about Malka, whom they all know. Tzippy is distressed that she inadvertently heard lashon hara.

The Chofetz Chaim says that the best thing to do in this situation is to try to immediately right the wrong. If at all possible, Tzippy should try to show everyone how in that story, Malka had really done nothing wrong, or that whatever she did was totally accidental and out of char­acter for her. If Tzippy knows that the woman who told the story dislikes Malka and will probably try to defend her version of the story, then she should wait until the woman is out of earshot before attempting to set the record straight.

IN A NUTSHELL

One is permitted to listen to lashon hara when he is reasonably cer­tain that there is a constructive purpose to such listening. Even then, he should not believe it as fact.

 -A project of  Mesorah Publications –

Categories
Daily Companion

Constructive Listening

In the previous segment, we learned that we are permitted to listen to loshon hora (without accepting it as fact) if there is something constructive to be gained. The Chofetz Chaim now poses an obvious question: How is this halachah applied in reality? How are you to know, before listening to a report, if the information can be used constructively?

The Chofetz Chaim offers the following guideline: If it is apparent that the speaker is about to say something negative about someone, then you should interrupt him and ask whether he thinks that there is something constructive to be gained from your hearing this information. If, for example, the person were to reply that the report could be valuable to the success of a business venture on which you are embarking, then you would be permitted to listen (provided that you do not accept it as fact). If it becomes clear that there is no toeless(constructive purpose) in listening, then it is forbidden to hear the report.

The Chofetz Chaim then discusses another case where one may listen to loshon hora.

Under normal circumstances, it is forbidden to listen to loshon hora spoken by one’s spouse, just as with any other individual. However, if someone has upset your wife very much and she is having difficulty coping, then you are permitted to help her through this situation by allowing her to unburden herself to you. While she is permitted to relate to you what has transpired, you should tell yourself that in her distress, she may be seeing things as worse than they actually are; you may not accept her words as fact. The Chofetz Chaim states that a primary goal in listening to the report should be to try to explain the situation in a positive light so that she will no longer be angry at the other person.

Obviously, this is not a carte blanche for husbands and wives to have free-ranging discussions concerning others. We are talking here about serious problems in which one can help one’s spouse overcome distress and make peace with the situation — and with the other party, if possible.

What if a person mistakenly listens to loshon hora when there is no constructive purpose? Then,says the Chofetz Chaim, he should try to correct hismistake by quickly finding a merit for the personwho is being maligned and authoritatively telling it to the speaker. In this way, the listener may succeedin convincing the speaker that he is guilty of misjudgment and that he has no reason to feel illwill towards the subject.

The Chofetz Chaim offers one more case of listening for a constructive purpose. You meet a friend who is angry about an injustice that was done to him. To your innocent question, “How are you?” he responds with a ferocious tirade against the culprit. As a friend, you have two choices. You can agree wholeheartedly with his complaints, so that his anger will continue to rage. Most probably, he will later rant and rave before another friend and then another … thereby causing the loshon hora to spread further. Or you can listen empathetically without showing approval. Then, when his anger had been defused, you can talk softly to him, calm him down and help him see the situation from a more positive perspective.

A baal loshon hora (habitual speaker of loshon hora) in this situation will listen to the tirade and fan the flames of baseless hatred, adding to our source of exile. Those who strive to live by the Torah’s requirements in these matters will use their power of persuasion to
uproot ill will, increase understanding and love for one’s fellow Jew, and help bring our Redemption one step closer.

Categories
Shmiras Haloshon

How to Get Insider Info

Categories
30 Seconds to Proper Speech Proper Speech

Helping Others to Improve

The first category of constructive purpose is to help the person about whom one is speaking. There is a tendency among many to ignore the misconduct of others in favor of a “live and let live” attitude. Let us first understand why the Torah rejects this attitude.

Every person is born with character flaws. It is our mission in life to change, to grow, to strive for perfection and spirituality. We all want to rid ourselves of our imperfections; people dowant to be good. What makes life so challenging is that negative character traits are blinding. We either lose sight of what our goals should be or rationalize to the point that we simply cannot differentiate between right and wrong.

One of the greatest gifts Hashem has blessed us with is companionship: friends, family, people around us who are close enough to care, yet distant enough to be objective. To abstain from speaking up and offering one another reproof and guidance amounts to depriving one another of one of the most valuable tools for personal growth. We must get involved and, when necessary, even enlist the involvement of others in helping people through the struggles of life. Remaining silent when reproof is called for is not Shmiras Haloshon, it is depriving one’s fellow of his lifeline to self-improvement.

Categories
Family Lesson a Day

Listening and Accepting

SEFER CHOFETZ CHAIM — Hilchos Lashon Hara 6:1-2

The Chofetz Chaim now turns his attention to the sin of kabbalas lashon hara, listening to and accepting lashon hara.

The Torah states: “Do not accept a false report.” This, says Mechilta, is the prohibition against accepting lashon hara. There are two aspects to this sin:

It is forbidden to intentionally listen to lashon hara even if we have no intention of believing it.

If we hear lashon hara, whether intentionally or unintentionally, we are not allowed to believe it.

The Chofetz Chaim points out that when a person believes lashon hara, his respect for the person about whom it was spoken is lowered. The mitzvah of ahavas Yisrael requires us to think well of other Jews, not to think less of them because of something that was said about them.

If someone is told lashon hara and responds by nodding in agreement, then he has been guilty both of accepting lashon hara and of speaking lashon hara.

Amazingly, Rambam states that the punishment of one who accepts lashon hara is greater than that of the speaker. Perhaps the reason is that if people would not accept lashon hara, then the evil report would be “D.O.A.” (Dead on Arrival). It would be harmless, and perhaps the speaker, seeing that his words were ignored, would not repeat this evil practice. The fact that the listener accepts the report as fact encourages the speaker to spread more lashon hara in the future.

There are times when it is permissible to listen to lashon hara. If a person feels that he must listen to lashon hara in order to save himself or someone else from physical or financial harm, he is permitted to do so. He may take the necessary steps on the possibility that the report is true, but he may not accept it as fact.

Raphael is on the verge of entering into a partnership with Naftali. The night before they are supposed to sign a contract to make it official, someone approaches Raphael and says, “I feel that I must warn you: if you enter into a partnership with Naftali, you will regret it.”

Raphael is permitted to ask the person, “On what basis do you make your statement?” He would then be permitted to listen to the person’s explanation as to why such a partnership would be harmful to him. Raphael would not be permitted to believe as fact whatever negative information he heard about Naftali. However, he would be permitted to — and he should — investigate the matter to the best of his ability. If his investigation indicates that the report is true, it would be perfectly correct for him to cancel plans for a partnership.

There are other reasons why a person would be permitted to listen to lashon hara without believing it. He may listen to it so that he can disprove it, or so that he can help make peace between Jews embroiled in a dispute, or so that he can be of help in correcting a wrong. As long as there is a beneficial reason for him to listen to the report, he may do so, provided that he does not believe it as fact.

IN A NUTSHELL

We are forbidden to intentionally listen to lashon hara. If we hear lashon hara, we are not permitted to believe that it is true.

 -A project of  Mesorah Publications –

Categories
Daily Companion

The Art of Listening

One of the factors which makes loshon hora such a serious sin is that it involves the interactionof two people — the speaker and the listener.Until now, the Chofetz Chaim has been dealingwith the speaker’s role. In this section, he puts thelistener under halachic examination, and states:It is forbidden to believe loshon hora. One whodoes so has transgressed a Torah prohibition (see Shemos 23:1 with Rashi).

The Chofetz Chaim quotes the teaching that the punishment for accepting loshon hora is greater than the punishment forspeaking loshon hora.The Chofetz Chaim further states that listening to loshon hora is forbidden even if the listener does not intend to accept the information. However, he notes, there is a difference between accepting loshon hora and listening with the intention of not believing what one is about to hear. And with this, we enter the complex issue of toeles, constructive purpose.

The Chofetz Chaim examines two common areas in which derogatory information might be required for a constructive purpose—the areas of business decisions and shidduchim (prospective marriage matches). If, for example, one is considering a job offer, a potential business partnership, or a suggested shidduch, he is permitted to listen to relevant negative information. His purpose in such cases is not gossipmongering, but self-protection. However, he must decide in his mind that while he may use negative information to protect himself, he will not accept it as fact. The Chofetz Chaim is discussing a case where the speaker initiated the conversation. The listener may “tune in” to the conversation l’toeles if either:

— the speaker has already made it clear that he is relating the information l’toeles; or

— The listener arrives when the speaker has already begun relating the information to someone else. This way, the listener is not guilty of causing someone to sin.

The allowance for listening for constructive purposes extends even further, the Chofetz Chaim says. One may listen to important information that applies to his friend to prevent the friend from falling into a bad situation. The listener should first check the accuracy of the information before passing it on to the relevant party. One can also listen to a report that his friend has committed a transgression, if he feels that he is in a position to speak to the person and help him mend his ways.

As mentioned, even when we are allowed to listen to negative information, we are not permitted to accept it as fact without further investigation. This seems to be a difficult demand. If I hear something about someone, and I act upon it, how can I not accept it as fact?

In reality, we do have a natural capacity to reject plausible information as false, and we exercise this capacity in many situations. For instance, imagine if you were to hear a terrible piece of loshon hora about your brother. The inner workings of your mind would immediately label this information as false. “I know my brother, and he wouldn’t have done something like that!” you would tell yourself. Nevertheless, because you care about your brother, you would probably confront him privately and say, “I cannot imagine that it is true, but I heard that…” The Torah requires us to view every Jew as a brother or sister, and extend our natural protective instincts to him or her as well.

Categories
Shmiras Haloshon

2 Reasons to Listen to Insider Info

Categories
30 Seconds to Proper Speech Proper Speech

In Summation

It is permissible to speak negatively about a person:

  1. to help the person, or
  2. to help anyone victimized by the person, or
  3. to resolve major disputes, or
  4. to enable others to learn from the mistakes of that person, provided that:
  1. one’s remarks are based on first-hand information and careful investigation, and
  2. it is apparent that this person is wrong, and
  3. the person has been spoken to but refuses to change his behavior, and
  4. the statement to be made will be true and accurate, and
  5. the intent of the speaker is for a constructive purpose only (and there is a reasonable chance that the intended goal will be accomplished), and
  6. there is no alternative means by which to bring about the intended result, and
  7. no undue harm will be caused by the statement.The illustrations presented below (as well as those to be discussed in the section on rechilus [gossip]) serve to clarify the application of these conditions.
Categories
Daily Companion

Marketing Tools and the Power of Two

In the business world, loshon hora is often spoken as a “marketing tool.” You may have observed this technique when asking a salesman for his opinion about a product and receiving, instead, a thorough denunciation of his competitor’s merchandise. “Well, that’s business,” is an often-heard expression. The Chofetz Chaim informs us, however, that such reasoning is never an excuse for speaking loshon hora.

Maligning competitors’ merchandise is an all-too-common practice. The obvious motivation behind this is a desire to increase one’s sales by minimizing competition. Sometimes there is a second motivation at work: jealousy. Someone with a product to sell finds it difficult to accept the fact that a competitor has better merchandise or better prices. Speaking loshon hora is his attempt at convincing others of what he would like to believe — that his item is superior. (In a later section, the Chofetz Chaim deals with a case where the salesman has only the customer’s benefit in mind.)

The Chofetz Chaim closes this section with an important point. When derogatory information is related by two people, the sin is even greater than if it had been spoken by one person. The reason for this is simple. A report has greater impact when more people give it credence. Think about it: If you hear derogatory information from just one person, you may accept it “with a grain of salt.” You may tell yourself, “I shouldn’t believe everything I hear.” Or you might tell yourself, “This speaker may be biased.”

But when you hear the same information from two people, you perceive it as a widely held notion. The second person has given the report added credibility. The Chofetz Chaim notes that even if one person delivers the initial report on his own and then a second person comes along and concurs with the report, the second person has also committed a grave sin.

In any conversation where loshon hora has been spoken, one may be tempted to add his comments in the belief that the damage has already been done and one more comment will not make a difference. This, too, is a serious mistake. Any additional comment is yet another transgression.

Categories
Shmiras Haloshon

Beware! The Most Popular Marketing Tool is Illegal

Categories
Family Lesson a Day

The Golden Rule: Nothing Negative

SEFER CHOFETZ CHAIM — Hilchos Lashon Hara 5:5-6

He is such a weakling!”

Someone unfamiliar with the laws of lashon hara might consider this a perfectly proper statement. “What did I say wrong? He is the nicest person I know — but he is a weakling!”

Such a statement is lashon hara if it could harm the person’s chances to earn a livelihood. The Chofetz Chaim offers two examples when this is possible: where the subject is a hired laborer or a rebbi.

No one would want to hire a laborer who is a weakling. And many principals would not want to hire a rebbi who is a weakling. It is often hard to find a good substitute for a rebbi and a principal might think that “a weakling” is more likely to miss school because of illness.

“He doesn’t earn a living — I know that for a fact.”

When word spreads that someone “is not earning a living,” others will be reluctant to loan him money. In both these cases, “If this will be publicized in the city,” says the Chofetz Chaim, “no one will want to extend credit to him, and this will cause him great harm and aggravation. This will affect his very existence — literally.”

As we have noted previously, if such information needs to be told l’to’eles (for a constructive purpose), then seven conditions, which will be discussed later, must be met.

“On the average day, he studies Torah for about three hours.”

“You can expect a $36 donation from him — that’s what he usually gives.”

Are such statements lashon hara? It depends about whom they are spoken.

To say that a man who works from 9:00 to 5:00 studies Torah for three hours a day is a great compliment. But if we are speaking about someone who is supposedly a full-time yeshivah student, then this statement indicates that something is amiss.

For a person who earns a modest living, a $36 donation is nice. But for a billionaire, it indicates stinginess.

When deciding whether or not a statement is lashon hara, we should follow Rambam’s rule: Any statement that can cause a person physical or financial harm; frighten him, or distress him, is lashon hara.

“What’s wrong with saying that he never gives a donation larger than $36? Neither do I!”

This is flawed logic, says the Chofetz Chaim. Perhaps the speaker is not ashamed to say this, because everyone knows that this is the most he can afford. The person of whom he is speaking, on the other hand, might be expected to give more.

Even if everyone knows that both men have identical jobs and earn the same amount of money, this does not necessarily permit such a statement, if people would expect them to give more. The fact that a person is not embarrassed by something does not grant him a license to say it about someone else.

IN A NUTSHELL

Never refer to someone as a “weakling” or say that he does less than would be expected of someone of his status. Being unashamed of your own faults does not give you the right to say that others possess these same faults.

 -A project of  Mesorah Publications –

Categories
Daily Companion

Dangerous Conjectures

The Chofetz Chaim informs us today that the popular pastime of “armchair financial analysis” is actually a forum for loshon hora. This occurs when a group conjectures about another person’s financial standing. The subject might be a neighbor, family member or wealthy individual in one’s city. Such discussions, without any real toeless (constructive purpose), are forbidden, as they can cause great damage.

Sometimes, the group concludes that, based on their information, the person is actually bankrupt, or at least deeply in debt. Such a conclusion can hurt the person in a concrete way. People who hear of this discussion may shy away from doing business with the person, or they may refuse to lend him money.

Obviously, says the Chofetz Chaim, if there is information that must be conveyed to a certain party to enable him to make a prudent business decision (l’toeles), then one can provide the information if seven conditions (which will be discussed later) are met.

The Chofetz Chaim then discusses the issue of “relative statements.” A given statement might be loshon hora when spoken about one person and high praise when spoken about another.

For example, imagine two people who are discussing the charity habits of some community members. “He’s good for $5,” one comments about a certain individual. If that individual is one of the richest men in town, then the statement would be loshon hora.

If, on the other hand, the subject is a poor person, the statement would not be loshon hora at all.

The Chofetz Chaim offers another example. If someone said of a rabbinical student, “He learns for four hours a day,” the listener would not construe this as praise. Yet if the same statement was said of a businessman with a hectic work schedule, it truly would be exceptional praise.

The Chofetz Chaim concludes by cautioning that, in the above cases, one cannot excuse his derogatory comment concerning the rich man or the rabbinical student by saying, “I wouldn’t mind if they said that about me!” Such rationalization completely misses the point. We have different expectations of different individuals, and what might be complimentary when said about one person could very well be derogatory when said about someone else.

Categories
Shmiras Haloshon

Do You Know How Much He’s Worth?

Categories
Family Lesson a Day

Unwarranted Criticism

SEFER CHOFETZ CHAIM — Hilchos Lashon Hara 5:2-4

“He’s a nice person, but he’s not that bright.”

“I’ve seen better contractors than him.”

“The rav knows what he needs to know for everyday she’eilos (halachic questions), but when it comes to a difficult piece of Gemara, he runs into problems.”

The Chofetz Chaim informs us that many people, out of sheer ignorance, are apt to make such comments, not realizing that such statements are pure lashon hara.

Lashon hara is any statement that either is derogatory or can cause the person harm is lashon hara. Can anyone honestly say that the statement “He’s not that bright” is not derogatory? In the Chofetz Chaim’s words:

I ask you, my brother: If you would discover, beyond any doubt, that someone announced publicly that you are not bright, wouldn’t you have a grievance against him? You would think to yourself, “What sign of foolishness did he see in me [that caused him to say this about me]? His statement is nothing more than an expression of his wickedness, and an indication that he is a baal lashon hara.”

All three examples above can cause the person irreparable damage. To say that someone is “not so bright” can hurt his shidduch opportunities. If he is married, it can lower his esteem in the eyes of his wife and in-laws. It can hurt his chances to find a job.

What if you are asked information about someone who applied for a teaching job and in your opinion, that person is “not so bright”? Such a situation has to be handled with great sensitivity; perhaps a halachic authority should be consulted. This is because your personal opinion about the person’s intelligence may not necessarily be correct. If it is correct, it does not guarantee that the person is not qualified for the teaching position. Perhaps he has many other great qualities, and with proper lesson-planning he will make a fine teacher.

“I’ve seen better contractors than him.” This statement can cause the contractor a loss of business, and could conceivably destroy his business. The only situation that might warrant such a statement is when someone who is considering hiring the contractor asks information about him. Even then, the “seven rules of to’eles (constructive speech),” which will be discussed in a later chapter, must be met.

“The rav knows what he needs to know for everyday she’eilos (halachic questions), but when it comes to a difficult piece of Gemara, he runs into problems.” This statement, even if true, is terrible. If the rav is fulfilling his role as spiritual leader of his community and teaching them how to live a life of Torah, then there is no reason to criticize him. Ridiculing the rav’s level of knowledge will serve only to lower his esteem in the people’s eyes. Then, when the rav instructs the people in the ways of the Torah, some of them might say, “Why should I listen to him? He’s not much of a talmid chacham, you know.”

The Chofetz Chaim writes:

Because the rav’s esteem was lowered in the eyes of the local populace, he might be removed from his position entirely. The speaker will have been responsible for [spilling] his blood and the blood of his offspring, for through his lashon hara, he has deprived him of his livelihood.

The speaker has also lowered the honor of Torah and its students very much; he has disgraced a talmid chacham, and for this, our Sages say, there is no remedy for his injury.

It does not take much to damage a person’s reputation. However, once it is damaged, it is often impossible to restore the reputation to what it once was.

IN A NUTSHELL

Criticism of a person’s intelligence or skills can do irreparable harm to his reputation.

 -A project of  Mesorah Publications –

Categories
30 Seconds to Proper Speech Proper Speech

Intent

Condition #6:

Having ascertained that:
1) The negative information is accurate,
2) The perpetrator was not justified,
3) Reproof has proven unsuccessful,
4) There are no other options,
5) The information will be related accurately:

Two more conditions must still be met before the information can be conveyed.

The speaker must be certain that his sole intent is l’toeles, for a constructive purpose. If he knows that in his heart he is pleased to cast the perpetrator in a bad light, he is not permitted to speak – even though the purpose cannot be accomplished any other way.

It is lowly to enjoy speaking negatively – even for a constructive purpose.

This is especially challenging when one is required to speak about a person whom he does not like. It is necessary to first eradicate any negative feelings towards that person; only then can the negative information be related.

Categories
Shmiras Haloshon

The Danger of Too Little Salt

Categories
Daily Companion

Opinion

In this segment, the Chofetz Chaim discusses assessments which people make regarding someone’s physical or mental abilities. It is common for people involved in everyday conversation to offer personal judgments about others which are less than flattering. Such statements can have far reaching consequences, especially in the area of shidduchim (marriage matches).

As the Chofetz Chaim notes, many people are unaware that analyzing a person’s attributes and verbalizing a less than flattering opinion of him is loshon hora. The example he offers is of someone who relates that the person under discussion lacks intelligence. Some might argue, “Wait — that’s not loshon hora. It’s true!” Obviously, these people are unaware of a fact which we have already stressed: A statement which is derogatoryand true is loshon hora.

One might also justify the statement by saying, “But it is not derogatory to say that a person isn’t smart!” In truth, Hashem has given each of us the exact combination of attributes we need in order to accomplish our purpose in this world. Unfortunately, however, most people do not consider this truth when they evaluate a person. If they hear that someone is not smart, their esteem for that person is automatically lowered.

The Chofetz Chaim warns us that by casually stating that someone is “not smart,” we may ultimately cause that person harm.

He offers three examples of how this could happen:

1. If the person is single, we will render him less desirable, and this will hurt him in a real sense as he seeks to get married.

2. Whether his livelihood is a craft, business or profession, people will be reluctant to deal with him, since most people like dealing with those whom they consider intelligent.

3. If he’s a rav or posek (halachic authority), then people will be reluctant to seek guidance or a psak (ruling) from him. His stature will be diminished, his feelings and his family members may be hurt, and ultimately, he might lose his position.

You might wonder, is it really possible that all of this can come from one small remark?

There is a famous story about the Chofetz Chaim and another rav, who were traveling together. They stopped at an inn, where the hostess recognized the two prominent rabbanim and ushered them to a table reserved for distinguished guests. After they finished a satisfying meal, the hostess returned to the table and inquired, “Did you enjoy the food?”

The Chofetz Chaim’s companion replied, “It was very good. But the soup could have used a little more salt.”

When the hostess left, the Chofetz Chaim, obviously distressed, informed the rav that his words constituted loshon hora. “Now the hostess will probably reprimand the cook, who is quite possibly a poor widow who must work to support her family.” The rav, however expressed his doubts that his seemingly benign comment could have such repercussions. The Chofetz Chaim then escorted him to the kitchen, where the two peered through the door and witnessed the hostess speaking harshly to the cook, a poor widow, who was in tears.

The rav hurried into the kitchen and said that the food had been quite good. He apologized to the cook and begged the hostess not to say anything more on account of his careless remark.

The moral is:

Think before you speak. Even a seemingly innocent comment has the potential to cause great harm.

Categories
Daily Companion

Intelligence

In this segment, the Chofetz Chaim further examines the common practice of discussing other people’s intelligence. He asks the reader to consider the following scenario:

You overhear a conversation in which you are the one who is being evaluated. Everyone involved in the conversation offers his or her own expert opinion, and the group then concludes that you have very little intelligence.

The Chofetz Chaim poses a simple question: “How would you feel?” The Chofetz Chaim answers the question: Your self-image would suffer a terrible blow. You would wonder, “What do they see in me that brings them to this horrible conclusion? Do I really show myself to be a fool?”

And you would conclude that this group’s real intent is evil — to degrade you in the eyes of those who know you. After all, what else could be their motivation?

Yet, as the Chofetz Chaim points out, with most people such conversations do not register even a faint “blip” on the subconscious “radar screen” which alerts God-fearing people when they are becoming involved in loshon hora.

In all probability, such talk will involve greater transgressions than words of loshon hora which are clearly derogatory. When, for example, a speaker attacks someone’s behavior, he may do so out of a sense of conviction. The subject has behaved in a terrible way (at least in the speaker’s opinion) and he wants to register his protest. While the laws of shmiras haloshon do not permit this, at least his intentions were good. By contrast, there is nothing to be gained from discussing someone’s level of intelligence; the only purpose could be to degrade the individual.

Such discussions can be more dangerous than those involving a person’s sins. If someone tells others that a person has sinned, the listeners may tell themselves that perhaps the circumstances were not exactly as had been related; or perhaps the subject had succumbed in a moment of weakness. By contrast, when people hear that someone is lacking intelligence, the natural tendency is to accept this as absolute truth. The listeners look no further. There are no excuses to consider. The person has been labeled, categorized and filed in their minds as “not smart.”

The Chofetz Chaim stresses that in any situation, derogatory comments concerning someone’s intelligence can have terrible repercussions. However, when one speaks negatively of the intelligence of a rav, Torah teacher, or of someone’s new son-in-law or daughter-in-law, the ramifications could be devastating.

We can avoid all these pitfalls by remembering the Chofetz Chaim’s question: “How would you feel if you were the one whose intelligence was being attacked?

In a nationwide test on shmiras haloshon for elementary school children, the question was posed: “What could you tell yourself that would help you to refrain from speaking loshonhora?” The most popular answer was, “By asking myself, ’How would I feel if I was in this person’s place?’ “The innocence of children often allows them to see matters more objectively than adults. These children were able on their own to arrive at the advice of the Chofetz Chaim — advice that we should all take to heart.

Categories
Shmiras Haloshon

I Know Your IQ

Categories
Family Lesson a Day

A Proper Teshuva

SEFER CHOFETZ CHAIM Hilchos Lashon Hara 4:12 – 5:1

Any time a Jew commits a sin, he is defying the will of Hashem. When he is ready to engage in teshuvah (repentance), he must embark on a three-part process:

1. Letting go of the sin and resolving not to repeat it in the future. Our Sages offer a parable of a person who immerses himself in a mikveh to purify himself from tumah and continues to hold a dead sheretz (creeping animal) — the cause of his tumah — in his hand! He can immerse himself all day and it will accomplish nothing. Until he lets go of the sheretz, he will not become purified.

Similarly, If someone sincerely wants to engage in teshuvah, his first step must be to stop committing that sin and to resolve not to repeat it in the future.

2. Regret – He must sincerely regret his sinful actions of the past.

3. Confession – He must confess his sin before Hashem.

Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch explained that the reason for confession is to ensure that the person will make a real effort to change. When we express with our lips what we have thought in our hearts, we are more likely to live up to it.

These three steps are required for any sin. When a sin is between man and his fellow, the sinner must also seek forgiveness. Speaking lashon hara is, of course, in this category of sin.

The Chofetz Chaim states: If a person speaks lashon hara and no one believes it, then he does not have to ask forgiveness, though he still needs to follow the three-step program outlined above for having sinned against Hashem. However, if even one person believed the lashon hara and this caused the victim emotional, physical, or financial harm, the speaker must ask forgiveness.

When a person has developed the terrible habit of speaking lashon hara regularly, it is virtually impossible for him to achieve complete teshuvah. How can he possibly recall all the people against whom he spoke? Even if he could recall them all, he will very likely be embar­rassed to approach some of his victims. If his lashon hara did damage to an entire family and this affected the good name of later generations as well, this would make full repentance impossible.

This segment concludes with a word of caution: Just as it is forbid­den to say that someone engages in conversation during davening, so it is forbidden to say that he did not want to extend a loan to someone. Mitzvos that are between man and Hashem and mitzvos between man and his fellow are equally important. To say that someone went against any sort of mitzvah is forbidden.

And surely, it is forbidden to say, “Yosef refused to extend a loan to me.” In this case, aside from the sin of lashon hara, the speaker is guilty of bearing a grudge, which is also forbidden by the Torah.

IN A NUTSHELL

Teshuvah for speaking lashon hara often requires seeking forgive­ness from the subject.

 -A project of  Mesorah Publications –

Categories
30 Seconds to Proper Speech Proper Speech

Be Accurate

Condition #5:

While derogatory information may be related for a constructive purpose, slander cannot be justified. One does not have the right to exaggerate or alter facts for a constructive purpose, nor may one omit details that minimize the severity of the person’s actions.

Indiscriminate use of superlatives such as “very” can easily distort facts way out of proportion. This is, in fact, a most common form of slander that people engage in, albeit unwittingly. Conversely, one must omit authentic details that make the story sound even worse if the result can be attained without their being mentioned.

Categories
Shmiras Haloshon

3 Steps to Damage Control

Categories
Shmiras Haloshon

Get Even

Categories
Daily Companion

Repairing the Damage

One of the greatest gifts Hashem has given the Jewish People is the ability to cleanse ourselves of our sins through teshuvah (repentance). This gift is especially precious when one has been guilty of speaking loshon hora.

We have learned that when we speak loshon hora, we cause untold damage to ourselves, to our listeners and to the subject(s) of our words. The Chofetz Chaim has chronicled in detail the many sins which can be transgressed through loshon hora. Yet regardless of how grievously we have sinned, Hashem extends to us the gift of teshuvah, enabling us to repair the damage, at least to some degree.

The Chofetz Chaim discusses the parameters of teshuvah as it applies to loshon hora. If one has spoken loshon hora but his listeners did not believe what was said, then the sin is one between man and Hashem. Teshuvah in such a case requires that the person regret his sin, confess it before Hashem, and accept upon himself never to repeat it.

If, on the other hand, the loshon hora was accepted as fact and it resulted in harm, then more is required. For example:

A person lost an opportunity for a promotion because someone provided unnecessary or inaccurate, negative information about him. This constitutes real damage, both monetary and emotional. In this case, the three-part teshuvah outlined above would not be sufficient. One would also have to approach the victim and ask forgiveness for having spoken against him and caused him harm.

Certainly, this is a very difficult thing to do, especially if the victim had been unaware that he was being considered for a promotion. Nevertheless, the Chofetz Chaim informs us that neither Yom Kippur, nor death itself, can erase a sin between man and his fellow man unless sincere forgiveness is sought and it is granted.

(The legendary founder of the Mussar Movement, Rav Yisrael Salanter, found difficulty with the above law. From a Mussar perspective, he suggested that if by telling a person that we spoke loshon hora about him, we will cause additional pain and distress, then perhaps it is better not to inform him).

The Chofetz Chaim sees this as one of the major pitfalls of speaking loshon hora. Often, people forget about whom they have spoken, or are unaware of the damage their words have caused. In such cases, warns the Chofetz Chaim, they will never have the opportunity to achieve complete teshuvah.

The Chofetz Chaim further cautions that we should be exceedingly careful not to malign entire families. This kind of loshon hora can create a bad reputation for the family which can last for generations and cause untold hardship.

The Chofetz Chaim once suggested the following for a person who wanted to repent for having spoken loshon hora, but could not remember about whom he had spoken: Such a person should become involved in spreading the teaching of shmiras haloshon. In this way, he will atone, to some degree, for the harm which his own words have caused.

Categories
Daily Companion

Between Man and His Fellow

In this segment, the Chofetz Chaim focuses on the mitzvah to extend loans to a fellow Jew. As the Torah states:” … When youlend money to My people …” (Shemos 22:24).

Consider the following situation:

You have a friend who is in need of a loan. He approaches someone you know and asks to borrow some money, but the prospective lender refuses, with the explanation that he cannot afford to extend a loan at this time. However, you happen to know the lender and you know for a fact that he does have the means to extend the loan. You assume that there is reason for his refusal is that he happens to be selfish.

Telling others of the person’s refusal to extend the loan is loshon hora. This is so even in a case where you witnessed the wrongdoing and even if your purpose in telling others is to protest the injustice done.

If the prospective borrower, in a desire to “get even,” tells others what happened, then he also transgresses the negative commandments against taking revenge and bearing a grudge (Vayikra 19:18).

The case of a loan request which was refused is used by the Chofetz Chaim as an example of loshonhora involving a person’s faults bein adaml’chaveiro, between man and his fellow. Similarly, it is forbidden to mention that someone is lacking in any of the interpersonal obligations which the Torah places upon us.

Even if a person were to repeatedly transgress one of these mitzvos—for example, he never extends loans despite the fact that he is fabulously wealthy –— it is forbidden to speak of it. As the Chofetz Chaim explains, we cannot categorize such a person as a rasha (wicked individual) because, unfortunately, many people mistakenly think of such obligations as being voluntary. Thus, they do not see themselves as sinners at all.